Thread: First LD! But Dangerous?

Congrats on your first LD!!! Must have been really exciting for you! I know I woke right up when I first knew I was having an LD, I think it's really cool that you didn't wake right up from the excitement! I've never heard of being physically hurt from having a dream, but then again I've never heard that you can't. I'll definitely check back again to see what others have said about it! Keep up the good work on the LDs!!!

They're (dreams are) occuring in your own head... so, no they cannot... I had something like that before, and it was because scratches/wounds I had only started getting inflamed while I was asleep..

So no, no physical harm can come to you during a dream unless of course SP malfunctions and you wind up on the floor, but that's very unlikely.

That's not to say that you won't feel physical pain in dreams...this can certainly happen and often does...only recently did I start to notice my tactile sense in dreams, and it's not always pleasent...maybe this sensation lasted into the waking state for you, or you had some very real scratches from before that only started hurting once you were asleep...

Anyway, the rest of your LD sounded fantastic, well done on all that,

and I hope you have more pleasant, painless LD's.

I highly highly highly doubt you can actually be physically hurt, I mean, it's all in the mind, right? I guess you could always trick your mind into thinking that you still feel the pain after being awoken but I don't see how there could be physical evidence.

I mysteriously get weird scratches and stuff all the time! It's kind of annoying actually.

It could be like a little stone or somthing like that in your bed , it hapens to me all the time , trust me mate stick with LDing

Congrats on the LD, but no, I'm 99% sure that nothing in the Dream world can hurt you in the real world. Besides, if the old man stabbed you in the leg, then surely your scratchmarks would be there.

It's all in your head.

Do you have a dog with large claws that likes sleeping on you by any chance?

Rather a cat. You have a cat?

Dreams cannot do physical harm to you. It is just not possible.

Originally Posted by Lord Toaster

Besides, if the old man stabbed you in the leg, then surely your scratchmarks would be there.

Thats what I was thinking too, but I didn't want to sound close-minded. I know some people believe in more supernatural things than I do...

Edit: But now does that make me naive to think that you could get hurt?

Some people think dreams physically hurt them. But it's usually a scratch or something that occurred in their sleep. My cat, for instance, still has her back claws... I may dream of something scratching me as I feel the pain.

Likewise, if I hear something in real life, some form of it may appear in my dream, too.

You can have dream pain without having a real life affliction, too, but it won't cause a real life affliction.

Thanks for replying,

btw I dont beilvive in supernatural things (skeptic) I was thinking about it from a scientific point of view, I probably scratched my chest when I was sleeping cuz I was in distress in the dream.

The thing is I dont do RC very often but I did in my dream. So now I set my watch to beep every hour and I do an RC. I'll see if that works tonight.

I LOVE LUCID DREAMS

Congrats on your ld, like most of the others have said, there's no way that you could have been physically hurt by your dreams... Keep up the great work!!

Originally Posted by Überschall

Rather a cat. You have a cat?

How about a girl?

Anyway, what I think is that the scratches happened before you went to sleep, and you don't remember getting them. It happens sometimes that you don't feel scratches at first, but later they become painful.

I've heard the theory that if you get hurt in your dream your body might actually react and send some extra blood to the area causing a red mark to appear. Could these be taken for scratch marks?

Originally Posted by dodobird

How about a girl?

Happened to me already, you don't want to ask....