Originally Posted by Alric
The reason people like to believe that being good gets them rewarded, and that being bad gets one punished is because of psychological reasons. It isn't that hard to see why a person would think good should be reward and bad punished, so it is easy to tell why the religions were created that way. There is no reason to actually believe such things. The world doesn't work like that. Good or bad is irrelevant. The only time those things effect anything at all is when humans try to enforce them. For example, killing a person doesn't result in any punishment what so ever, unless another human makes a rule saying it isn't allowed and is willingly to enforce that rule
Back to the main question though, the chances of an afterlife seem pretty slim. There are a few real, scientific possibilities that could result in an after life being real. For example, if we are in an extremely advanced simulation of the universe, it is possible all that information can be backed up and saved. In which case, there is a possibility that the owner of the simulation can use your data in other ways, and thus have you continue your life some where else. That is pretty out there, but theoretically possible.
I agree with you - but I would want to add the possibility of automatic self-punishment, when your empathy systems kick in, maybe after the deed.
Of course this is in no way guaranteed, but I think we humans as social animals have some restraints, some "morals" programmed into us, including self-punishment and reward triggered in our psyche, and executed on the level of neurotransmitters and hormones.
When you act kindly, help another human being - that sets in motion positive feelings, doesn't it? And hurting somebody tends to hurt yourself to some degree, if not overshadowed by strong negative emotions towards that being, or when your restraints have been overridden by getting used to it, like in wars, but one can't completely rid oneself of it, normally. Would the denomination psychopath fit somebody who can?
But generally - I think, people need to adapt to being a soldier and killing people, need to somehow short-circuit this reaction not to go mad.
Seems the so called mirror neurons play a crucial role here: Mirror neuron - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
Whatever - there is no conceivable possibility for an afterlife as it is, except you follow this simulation idea. Maybe one day it could be possible, if consciousness functioned like that, that a person's "mind" with memories and personality and everything could be transferred onto another medium, and one could live on there in a virtual reality, not unlike dreams. Depends, if such a thing is theoretically possible, and we're far from being able to answer this question at the moment.
Consciousness without a matrix - how can one expect that to be possible?
What do you think, we need this extremely complicated brain of ours for?
How come you "believers" are aware, that damage to the brain robs us of crucial functions, including consciousness itself, but you believe that complete loss of it wouldn't result in complete disintegration?
It's unreasonable wishful thinking, that's all it is in my eyes.
|
|
Bookmarks