Official DV startrek fan thread!

**Man of Shred** · 10-27-2008 04:59 AM

My favorite series in order, the first being my most liked.

1. Voyager.
2. deep space nine.
3. The Next generation.
4. Enterprise (series could have been cooler with a few more seasons)

discuss or post your fav star trek vids please!

**wannywan** · 10-28-2008 10:18 AM

I'd have to agree there with Voyager being the best, although it often gets slated as the worst and I haven't a clue why!

I have no time for Enterprise though, from what I've seen it just isn't Star Trek in my opinion.

**Xaqaria** · 10-28-2008 11:31 AM

In before "star wars is better"

Ooh yes! I win the thread

**Man of Shred** · 10-28-2008 03:23 PM

Originally Posted by wannywan

I have no time for Enterprise though, from what I've seen it just isn't Star Trek in my opinion.

It took a while to get into it. but it is pretty good it deserve at least one watchthrough of all 4 season. I never liked deep space nine at first. but after a few seasons i began really enjoying it.

**wannywan** · 10-28-2008 11:48 PM

Deep Space Nine really blows hot and cold for me, some episodes are some of the best in the whole Star Trek-verse, while others aren't as good.

Maybe I should give Enterprise a chance. I suppose it coincided with a relative lull in my Trekkie fandom.

**spockman** · 10-29-2008 04:11 AM

I'd have to agree there with Voyager being the best, although it often gets slated as the worst and I haven't a clue why!

Firstly, some people don't like how Janeway pretty much breaks every code of good leadership recognized by the military a dozen times each... And during about the middle third of the series it seemed like every third or fourth episode was based on a temporal anomoly. And it didn't pose the gray ethical questions like TNG did. Moral decisions where there, but they didn't have as much depth as those presented in, say, 'I, Borg' or 'The Defector.' And sometimes the drama level seemed a little... forced. I'm not saying that it was bad. These are just some of the most popular reasons why trekkie don't like Voyager.

I have no time for Enterprise though, from what I've seen it just isn't Star Trek in my opinion.

Yes, it doesn't feel like Star Trek at all. While TOS to TNG have major differences in presentation, TNG still felt like Star Trek. The style isn't even remotley similar. It's not the same tone... For that reason I've never gotten into it. Plus, it sometimes tried to hard if you know what I mean. It tried to explain discrepencies between episodes that no-one cared about and sometimes the explanations where really lame.

I never liked deep space nine at first. but after a few seasons i began really enjoying it.

I was captivated by some DS9 episodes. But it didn't have the elements that I most love about Star Trek. The element of problem solving and pushing past obstacles like can be seen in 'The Corbomite Maneuver.'

My favorite was TOS. I can definitly understand why some people like TNG better, as I also really love The Next Generation. I've watched quite a bit of Voyager and was entertained but not much more. Enterprise I never got into. Same with DS9, though I've seen a good deal more of it than I have of Enterprise.