Printable View
Does anyone do it? You think about something without saying the words out in your head, you just think of the concepts. Also, does anyone read without saying the words in their heads, just seeing the words and making sense of them?
I want to see if I'm alone or not...
I can do it willingly, but day to day basis I usually say the words first and then make the image. Silmarillion is a wonderful book to make imagery straight from the words.
http://www.ecoefx.com/prodimages/col...atches/red.gifQuote:
Originally Posted by PR0G4P4RV18
You just did.
I don't think I've ever tried reading without hearing or imagining the sound. It's a necessary intermediate step towards creating the image.
But I think in concepts. When I think hard or am developing a new concept, you will see me struggling to visualize things, using my hands to manipulate imaginary physical manisfestations of them. But I can reverse the process of converting words into concepts and tell you of them. Check the links in my sig. (Product Placement!)
redQuote:
Originally Posted by Daniel Danciu
At first, no verbalization.Quote:
Originally Posted by Daniel Danciu
Yes, shortly afterward: Red, pink, tinge, shape - square, empty etc.
It can be a choice to think words, though it's not necessary in most cases. :D
You actually think with words? I've never done that before. I remember my friend asking me the question, and I looked at him strangely. I didn't know you could think with words, all I ever see is images. The only time words are in my thoughts is when I read something, or if I'm talking to myself. How does one read something without saying the word in their mind? I'd love to learn that.
When I looked at this... I saw many different things. I saw myself, I saw people running around, and I saw a large city. I could hear noises and kids playing, and much more.Quote:
Originally Posted by Daniel Danciu
I do that with japanese since it's not my native language and they use kanji which are more like pictures in order to communicate...
I do, but I think super fast, I don't have the time to think of the words.
I actually read super slow, since I create what is happening in my mind. I visualize the characters, setting, and hear their voices...but I recreate it every line i read or so...
I remember reading in one of my old textbooks that the majority of people (around 90% if I remember correctly) tend to subvocalize all or most of their thoughts, but that a minority of people do so rarely, if ever. I think that for most of us, one of the only times that we aren't thinking in words is when we are consciously trying to visualize something (or recreate any other kind of sensory experience).Quote:
Originally Posted by freak
I'm not sure that there are any significant implications for the minority of people who tend not to think in words, but I do think that it's interesting.
Yeah, that's pretty much what I do. Let's say I was hungry, I'll start to see images of my favorite foods appearing in my thoughts but I never say "I'm hungry" or the name of the food. My imagination was always fueled by my emotion, and that's both an advantage and a disadvantage. I very rarely think, and my mind is at rest the majority of the day. I do have "inner dialogue", which is just conversation with myself (I'm crazy lol), and that and reading are the only times words are in my mind. Whenever I go for a walk, I do a sort of astral projection where I tend to overlap this reality with my own, and I can see my characters walking along side me. I hope that one day I can completely overlap this one with my own... if that's even possible.
I think you can think without words....to be honest, I think words slow everything down in general, and there are times where it's better to think without thinking in words....they only slow thought down.
I see words more like....anchors for thoughts <----hell yeah, that was impressive!
I think so fast I have time neither for concepts nor words
It depends on how you define thinking.
Different people think differently.
I usually think in words, but sometimes I get onto a thought train that just doesn't stop. When I enter that state, I do not use words, nor pictures, I use more feeling. Those thoughts are aroused by thinking about my actions and the reactions of those actions, or how things could be perceived in different ways that may lead to certain views. I'm not quite sure how else to explain it. These thoughts are usually ones that I get frustrated at because I cannot quite explain their to myself with words, though I still know what they mean.
occasionally during my math class I can get answers from problems that don't require a lot of matematical processing. When that happens it feels like I'm thinking in varying degrees of emotion (best I could describe the feeling).
Thinking without words does not exist because to think requires you to use symbolic thought.
In other words, we have adapted to think WITH words since 45,000 BCE.
At least that's my 2 cents.