:)
You remind me of myself in my early years. And don't get me wrong it's a good thing, you need to make the misstakes in order to learn what is best for you.
But I will give you an advice that I am almost 100 % that you will NOT FOLLOW, because I had people telling me the exact same thing, but I did the misstake over and over for about 2 years... Let's just say that I know how it is like to try to find the BEST METHOD. :content:
I am going to give you an explanation a video and a small advice, in my attempt to try to make you understand a misstake that you haven't even done yet, but that I am will try to prevent you from making. It sounds like I come from the future ... But well this beginner misstake is very common, and I have lots of experience with these kind of questions.
Ok first of all, here is a test to see if I can read your mind. I will begin by telling you that I recall about 4-6 dreams every night and that I had 3 (long) lucid dreams this morning (which is very rare for me) and I have about 5 lucid moments (which is just realizing that you are dreaming for 3-10 sec) each week. And here is the magic:
And the answer will shock you, but I'll wait with that. ^-^
Here is the video:
Advanced lucid dreaming: part 6 - YouTube also watch part 7!
And here is my advice: Frequent lucid dreams have less to do with what method you use and more to do with what you think!
And here is my induction technique: The ways I enter a lucid dream is either direct (WILD) or indirect (DILD) and the method I use is...
NOTHING! I don't read a tutorial or a guide or create my own kind of induction method and follow that, I just sleep.
Ok if I would explain what I do you would probably say that I use a method (like meditation or something) But what I have done is that I made it a habit so it's not even a practise anymore, I just do it and it's typical sleep for me. Just like a reality check becomes effective when it becomes a habit, the lucid dreaming methods does too.
It's like using the methods as training wheels and when you understand why something really works, you can do it naturally.
I know the basics and the mechanics and even the chemical reactions in the brain for WILD and DILD, but I don't force that, I just let it happen.
I am going to give you a weird example but a useful one for lucid dreaming. Imagine lucid dreaming to be just like making a girl like you.
If you go to her with the intent of making her in love with you or to hit on her, you will be nervous, judge yourself and well probably fail.
But! If you go and talk to her as a friend and behave like yourself, just like you are around your best friend, you will show confidence, be secure and not worry about the outcome because you are there to have fun, not to kiss her. And how many theories there might be about picking up girls or how to make a girl like you, it will all come naturally if you behave naturally! You can of course use some small "how to make a girl like you" methods until you naturally are that guy, because methods are just instructions of how to make something natural. It will also be more rwarding if she likes you when you are yourself and not some made up version you did just to make her like you.
The same goes for lucid dreaming, if your intent only is on getting that lucid dream one night, you will be nervous, judge yourself and probably fail.
But! If you fall asleep naturally and fall asleep happy, confident you will also dream peacefully. And how many theories there might be about lucid dreaming, it will all come naturally if you practise naturally, be yourself, not a method. You can of course use some small "how to lucid dream" methods until you naturally are that guy, because methods are just instructions of how to make something natural! It will also be more rewarding since you can give yourself the credit and not some method.
But use the method don't let the method use you!
This became a very long post and I will try to make it end. But a good advice might be to learn from your attempts and not judge them.
But to comment on your idea here, try it :) But remember that the success is more depending on what you think than on what you do.
To not make you confused I will just say that I do use methods, but I don't actively choose "ok tonight I am going to DEILD or WBTB", I just let it happen, if I wake up during the night I DEILD if my awareness feels dreamy but if it doesn't I WBTB. So you see I use the methods, I don't let the methods use me.
The only active "method" I use consciously would be the WILD, however I do it to sleep consciously not to induce a lucid dream, because that comes naturally.
However I feel like I kind of failed to convince you, because of the simple reason that there was no substantial information at all in this post... :P
So if you need any help I would be happy to help you, and I will try to post something more concrete xD
But I guess what I am trying to say is that you should see methods as tools, and understand that the only thing you need to lucid dream is to sleep. :sleepmeditate2:
And if you need help to understand any tool or how to use them, I am glad to help you. =)