Well, I've heard a lot of people talking about this lately. I had this discussion with a friend who explained it was technically possible according to modern physics, you just had to squeeze yourself inbetween two black holes. And we all know that's a daily activity for almost anybody. I was thinking about it, and I thought up this little reasoning that seems to prove time travel is impossible. I don't use time paradoxes to prove my point, nor do I use scientific argument. I've kept it as clean-cut as possible. But what I'd like is some input on it, to see if I made an error somewhere, and what people think about it. So here we go.
Suppose time travel is invented in 2020, by a guy I will refer to as the Mullet Man (kudos if you get the reference.). The Mullet Man decides to use his newfound powers of timetravel to travel back in time to the year 2000, where he becomes the first King of America. Under his rule, America experiences a golden age. However, the Mullet Man dies of a heart attack in 2025, and a new King is elected. Then, in 2040, a treatement is discovered that will allow people to live at least twice as long as was previously possible. A doctor goes back in time to 2020, and treats the Mullet Man so he will survive his heart attack, and he lives to rule America for a great deal longer.
Now, that's our scenario. Suppose you are a person living in this time period, in America. Now, let's also say that if the Mullet Man did not come to America to be crowned king, the whole country would have been destroyed in a civil war. In 2000, what happens? Well, the Mullet Man arrives, and he is crowned king, obviously. But what happened to the other timeline, the one where America is destroyed in a civil war? It never happened. That timeline, as far as you are concerned, never existed. Let's skip ahead to 2020. This is when the doctor arrives to treat the Mullet Man to live longer. Again, what happened to the other timeline of him dying of a heart attack? It never existed. But, there's even another timeline beneath that one, the one were America was destroyed. That was replaced by the one where the Mullet Man died of heart attack, which in turn was replaced by the Mullet Man getting treated to live longer.
Now comes the crucial point. So, if you are a person that goes through a timeline, you will only experience the last of the timelines, none of the iterations that came before it. Now, the conclusion is fairly simple. The reason that you can't change this timeline is, because it is the last of the timelines. If you changed it, it wouldn't be the last of the timelines, so you couldn't have experienced it, which means you wouldn't have a timeline to alter the time from. And that's the whole point. You can't timetravel because all the timelines you will ever experience are nessecarily ones that cannot be changed.
I hope I explained that properly. Thoughts? Critisism? Additions?