Is the universe infinite?
There's always been an argument that has irritated me about why the universe cannot be infinite. It goes like this:
If there were an infinite number of stars, every line of sight would end on a star, hence the night sky would be white. The night sky is not white, hence the number of stars is finite.
I don't see how that holds water at all personally, yet I still find it mentioned in major books such as a Brief History of Time.
It's well known that if you add up an infinite number of positive numbers, you don't necessarily get infinity.
For example, 1 + 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + 1/16 etcetera = 2; not, as you might be inclined to think, an infinite value, nor even a remotely large value.
So here's the deal with the whole infinite stars thing: as a star gets further away from us, it takes up less space in the sky. As a very crude way of expressing my argument (yet nonetheless valid, I think), let's say there is a star 1 lightyear away, which takes up 1 unit of area in the sky. The next star in this particular universe is 2 lightyears away in another direction and takes up 1/2 a unit of sky. The next star is 4 lightyears away, and takes up 1/4 units of area; the next 8 lightyears and 1/8 units, 16 and 1/16, and so on.
Surely if this universe existed, although there would be an infinite number of stars in the sky, the stars would only take up a total of 2 units of area.
Hence, an infinite number of stars does not necessarily imply a white sky; and a sky which is not white does not necessarily imply a finite number of stars.