Are you living in a democratic country?
Printable View
Are you living in a democratic country?
Lol bah I smell the Irrefutability Fallacy.
Lol. Many mistakes here. If he knows everything in a given instant, then he also knows the outcome of it. Same thing of weather forecast: if you know the characteristics of the weather now, you are able to predict what it will be like tomorow.
And if he is indeed omnipotent (which is also logically impossible), then he should have teh ability to take his omniscience ability off, yeah. But then you can't say god is omniscient anymore.
So, either god is really smart and sins don't exist, or he is a childish fool, and we disappoint him for it.
either way it contradicts people's beliefs in god lol,
From now on I officially have a crush on Carôusoul xD
You make a big time mistake:
If he is omnipotent (all powerful) there is nothing that he cannot do, and yet you offer a limitation.
Say hypothetically I am verbally intelligent, but I decide not to speak for one day. Would it be fair and logical to then say that I am not verbally intelligent?
Your arguing against yourself. Seriously;
the point he is making is an example of your point.
So literally, you are arguing with yourself.
Don't respond Kromoh.
Work this one out for yourself PS. Read carefully through the responses and think.
Because right now it seems you are arguing for the sake of argument.
lol
Repeating Carou's example long ago:
If god is omnipotent, is he able to create a rock so big that he cannot lift?
If yes: then he isn't omnipotent, because he cannot lift that rock.
If no: then he isn't omnipotent, because he isn't able to create such rock.
That proves omnipotence is logically impossible.
Concerning my argument, it's hard to make false hypotheses based on false hypotheses.
EDIT: lol carou we posted simultaneously. Now I'm done being a witness for the case ^^
I thought you'd finished?
...except from a purely philosophical standpoint, if he CAN, but he DOESN'T, then his omnipotence isn't in jeapordy :P
But not to worry, there is a way around this:
Religions (at least most mainstream ones) hold that god has given us free will. So then, if he doesn't necessarily have control over our actions, then he isn't omnipotent. Instead of "stone he cannot lift", using "person whose will he does not have control over" works, since it's the entire basis of "faith" :)