Hey, PresentMoment, you are still here; I thought you might have left the game...
Here are a couple of quick responses to your follow-up:
I think I already stated most of my theory about why most people have little interest in LD'ing when I said:
But let me add this clarification. Lucid dreaming is a near perfect "You had to be there" event to describe, and even the best descriptions tend to go unheard when they land on ears belonging to people who have no interest in things like dreams, consciousness, sense-of-self, or LD'ing, which combines all those "boring" and strange subjects. It's sort of like the problem a motorhead faces when trying to describe his recent success rebuilding a Weber 6-pack on the first try to a person with no interest in cars, much less the intricacies of vintage carburetors.Quote:
I learned quickly that most people aren’t terribly interested in dreams at all, and those who are hold very specific viewpoints of them which rarely dovetail with mine. ... More importantly, though, I hold dreaming as a very personal event, to the point where others -- even other accomplished LD’ers -- simply will not understand what I’m saying because they lack the context of my experience in specific dreams, and vise-versa (which is the main reason I don’t post DJ entries, BTW).
I actually wrote a couple of novels which are centered on my take of the potentials of lucid dreaming and dream sharing respectively, yet even my family members can't generate enough interest in dreams to pick one of them up. If dreams are not a part of your life's experience, then you are likely going to be very disinterested in LD'ing.
On rereading this bit, I think I still haven't answered your question; perhaps my "theory" is simply that dreams, because they are generally forgotten upon waking, are simply of no real interest to most people -- they don't even care much about their own dreams, except perhaps those few that they remember and to which they attach often very undreamy meaning. So, if people don't give a crap about their own dreams, why should they care about mine?
Regarding the rest of your post, I think we'll have to agree to disagree on the philosophy bit because you are correct when you suggest that "this isn’t meant to be a ‘everyone debate Sageous thread’," but I would like to clarify one concept:
When I say “everything around you is literally you” in a dream, what I mean is quite simple and by no means meant to sound deep or mystical. The point here is that when you are in a dream, the entire universe around you has been manufactured by your own mind. Understand that when you are self-aware in a dream, and your interaction with that part of your mind with which you are rarely in direct contact will be much more productive (and easy); it's that simple.
However, if you enter a LD sure that there is a separate brain "out there" somewhere with which you can only associate through observation or requests, then you will likely miss much of what LD'ing has to offer, because for me LD'ing represents a unique conscious connection to your unconscious mind.
This I think may be more fundamental than the fundamentals: LD'ing is all about connections, and to deny that those connections are possible is to deny the potentials of both LD'ing and waking-life self-awareness. Wouldn't it be better, for instance, to assume you can fly, and ultimately build an airplane, than it would be to believe that "If man were meant to fly, he'd have wings," and never even imagine powered flight, much less build a plane?
I know you don't agree with me, but you also will not deter me from repeating that all of it -- brain activity, consciousness, unconsciousness, memories, the dreamscape, etc -- is a part of you. I think to consider consciousness as just some outside, accidental, powerless side-effect of your body's physical and psychological existence will do a lot to stymie the development of your LD'ing skills, much less future spiritual growth and experience in sleeping and waking life.
Maybe you can look at it from this fairly cynical perspective: even if I'm wrong, my LD'ing experience is richer for believing that my mind is my own, and that everything in my dream is a reflection of my Self ... that's how expectation works! To go into a dream assuming yourself an outsider in your own world is not a great idea, I think.
Also, should you finally learn to change dreamscapes at will (or more), I think you will be pleasantly surprised to discover that it actually is You doing the creative work, and that changes in a dream really are not the result of a distant "brain" processing a request from its lowly user. Yes, your brain is involved, but you are a part of the process, and not an observer. Like it or not, to say otherwise will belittle the experience, and hold you back from truly transcendental events.
Again, I really see no point in arguing this here, but I wanted to clarify that point, as I felt it was important.
So thanks for coming back to the thread, and, of course, for the kind words!