Originally Posted by
Spock
Ahh, I see what you mean now... Well, I think my user name makes it fairly likely that I'm not a religious person and wouldn't be considered spiritual in the common sense... ;)
But to me this seems to be a matter of interpretation, really. Whether one thinks that a DG is an actual spiritual other-worldly being or simply a mentor figure influenced by RL experience, it isn't like these are two distinct types but rather distinct interpretations of the same phenomenon. That's how it seems at least to me. I mean, one could argue that the being behind the "image" of Sivason in your dream is some sort of a spiritual being as well, just hiding behind a face you'll see as appropriate. Either way, to me a dream guide is a DC that is either more lucid or more in control than your own dream self, sometimes a reoccurring character (both interpretations fit in this definition).
To me the question is, is it possible to make an artificial character that is persistent and that "important" to your subconscious, that it will become a DG? If it's achievable (or more specifically, achievable for me), I agree - I see no reason for it to function any differently from a spontaneous DG. :)