Thread: Right-minded or Left-minded... which are you, and why?

Originally Posted by SolSkye

The dispute between rationalism and empiricism concerns the extent to which we are dependent upon sense experience in our effort to gain knowledge. Rationalists claim that there are significant ways in which our concepts and knowledge are gained independently of sense experience.

Im a bit confused . Can you give an example in which our concepts and knowledge are gained dindependentl of sense expereince? Is that even posisble without using the senses?

Originally Posted by dragonoverlord

Im a bit confused . Can you give an example in which our concepts and knowledge are gained dindependentl of sense expereince? Is that even posisble without using the senses?

2 + 2 = 4 (sense experience), therefore 2 + 2 + 2 + 2 = 4 + 4 (rational analysis)

oh ok in that sense. I thought they meant it in a different way...

I am far more of the imaginative sort, though fully able to apply rationality and reason when required. I don't like it though, and I don't like what I tend to become when life's requirements force me to go there.

I just spent three WEEKS there because of a legal situation. We prevailed - it went down on Monday. Monday evening, I was so looking forward to getting together with the band and just relaxing and falling back into that state of mind I am most comfortable in... but I couldn't do it. I was still stuck in reason. The evening was frustrating and nothing magical came out of it. I left there feeling like I had forgotten how to play.

It's coming back to me now, but the striking thing was recognizing just how fully I had locked into that mode for the day and how difficult it was for me to switch back out of it. It doesn't seem like it should be an "either/or" scenario, but in extreme situations it does become that for me.

Anyway, I'm right-brained by preference and nature. It is where I gravitate to.

I am right-handed therefore I am left-minded. But I think I am at least slightly right-minded, too, cuz I like all the spiritual and dream stuff. Left-minded looks cooler, but I cant help myself.

The whole right-brained, left-brained thing is a brainscam, please stop spreading this stuff. It's like the "we only use ten percent of our brains", or the "inducing alpha waves leads to deeper consciousness", etc.

I dont think he means litterally all the right brain info is imaginitive and vice-versa, he is just using it to ask a question. In this sense, I am slightly on the logical left side, though I do entertain paranormal ideas, and am good at music, I usually try to find the rational reason to something first, so I guess that makes me slightly left. and solskye you have yet to answer my question in "ask me about seeing aura's" topic

The whole concept of this dichotomy is pretty much groundless, if you ask me.

For one thing, it suggests that people who are verbally talented are not likely to be artistic, but research suggests otherwise.

"Rationalists" often have the most successful imaginations, incorporating what they know to come up with new models and explanations of how things work. These 'dreamers' you refer to are basically rationalists without the actual knowledge - just the ability to make up stuff that's probably irrelevant to reality.

^^^ gee, I wonder what he is *snickers*

*runs off to play make believe*

Originally Posted by Aquanina

^^^ gee, I wonder what he is *snickers*

*runs off to play make believe*

Awesome post .

I'm inclined to be right-brained.

Originally Posted by thegnome54

The whole right-brained, left-brained thing is a brainscam, please stop spreading this stuff. It's like the "we only use ten percent of our brains", or the "inducing alpha waves leads to deeper consciousness", etc.

Originally Posted by SolSkye

Originally Posted by thegnome54

I'm right, and you're wrong. I have all the knowledge and understanding, and you can't even begin to understand my greatness. Now bow down before the mighty gnome! Muahaha.

Originally Posted by SolSkye

child-like stubbornness on your part

You're the one throwing out childish personal attacks.

The 'vein' of this thread seemed to me to be entirely based on the concept of right-brain, left-brain. Maybe it's just all of the poll options using this terminology, or the whole paragraph and numerous false images you posted discussing this concept. If I was somehow wrong about this, and all of that was really not what you meant to discuss, you could tell me nicely instead of lashing out at me. Grow up.

Reread your opening post, man.

The entire thing is about your ideas on how 'dreamers' and 'rationalists' differ, along with a bunch of pictures depicting the right-brain left-brain thing. My comment is clearly not nit-picking, since your WHOLE POINT revolves around this concept.

If all you're after is a bunch of numbers in your poll, you're in the wrong forum. I apologize for assuming you were looking for some sort of discussion about this.

Do you have links or some sources for this being false Gnome?

I've seen this idea a lot of places(which I accepted as fact), I'd be interested to see a site or article of what you're saying.

Originally Posted by Grod

Do you have links or some sources for this being false Gnome?

I've seen this idea a lot of places(which I accepted as fact), I'd be interested to see a site or article of what you're saying.

Sure:
http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?id=...ing-brainscams

That's the actual article I based my post on. Also, during my summer course at Brown, the professor discussed the 'right-brain, left-brain' issue with us for a while, and expressed the same general sentiment that it's an oversimplification and that even though the brain halves are indeed different in structure and function, people have not shown to use one half 'more' than the other.

Thanks.

Man, that had been indoctrinated in me since I was born.

It is true that there is an emerging school of thought that the old theories of brain hemisphere dominance are wrong. However, as far as I know, the vast majority of psychologists, psychiatrists, and neurologists still hold to the left and right brain dominance theory. It is not really about which side of the brain a person uses more. It is about which side works better. There is a reason that Joni Mitchell can create some of the most beautiful sounds ever heard and have trouble making much sense in a conversation while some of the greatest scientists I know would have trouble drawing a stick man.

This is somebody with extreme right brain dominance. Her music speaks volumes, and what she says to the audience speaks volumes.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=bIZOtykZ0fA

Another right brain extreme:

http://youtube.com/watch?v=NZizdexKfDA

http://youtube.com/watch?v=PxIlXXNvvTI

This is somebody with (most likely) extreme left brain dominance.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=iqX1rX3zLfU

This guy too...

http://youtube.com/watch?v=AHylem7AwZU&feature=related

I think I am about equally left and right brained.

Gnome I never really thought about that whole left-right brain thing enough to question it. So thanks for pointing that out.

P.S. So I guess that spinning dancer thing doesn't really mean anything?

No matter what the physiology may or may not be, there is clearly, (to me, based on my lifetime of observation,) a continuum with hard rationality on one end and emotive on the other. Few of us live our lives at one end or the other of that continuum, but most of us spend most of our time somewhere off-center one way or the other.

I know what my own preference is.

I'm with pj on this. My own observation has shown me enough to believe what I do.

If this is the result of one side working better than the other, it also would stand to reason that you use it more too. Take one of the best examples, the left and right hand, each controlled by the opposite hemisphere. It's apparent that an individual uses the hand that suites them best.

Originally Posted by thegnome54

The whole concept of this dichotomy is pretty much groundless, if you ask me.

For one thing, it suggests that people who are verbally talented are not likely to be artistic, but research suggests otherwise.

"Rationalists" often have the most successful imaginations, incorporating what they know to come up with new models and explanations of how things work. These 'dreamers' you refer to are basically rationalists without the actual knowledge - just the ability to make up stuff that's probably irrelevant to reality.

You are the one that makes this idea seem irrational. The reason being is because someone who is not artistic and is right handed jumps on the defensive. One who is left handed and would like to be mathematically inclined does just the same. What I wish to know is why do people think that an idea has to be all or nothing. As if this theory is to say there are no left brain artists, no right brain scientist That's the silly part.
We have two hemispheres and each hemisphere has shown proficiency or dominance in certain areas. This can be seen through brain scans and tests, it is not just a rational guess.
Why would some people be left or right handed, just happenstance?

Why wouldn't an individual be more proficient at some tasks than others?

We of coarse can train or minds to work in both hemispheres, The Jugglers
The Hemi-sync© series are a method to get both hemispheres in sync with each other. Same with binaural beats. Both hemispheres coordinating together would obviously make for more profound results

I was coached a few times by a french tennis coach who completely changed his technique of teaching after going away to study on some course or other. When he came back, he told us to forget what we'd already learnt, effectively to throw the "Rule Book" away, because he was going to experiment on us with "Right-brained coaching" (sic).

It was really simple.. if the ball bounced in front of you, you had to say out loud the word "bounce".. when you hit the ball, you had to say "hit", unless you were at the net, in which case you had to say "touch".. so you just had three words to learn to say. He said that once these words were ingrained in us, our "instincts" would take over and we would become much better players. The results were amazing.. you stopped thinking about your shots, where to put them etc., and something else took over. After a couple of such lessons, I found myself playing shots of which I could only previously dream, without consciously thinking about them. Strange stuff.

From my experience it seems the idea of this division is usually spread by people that then love to shout how they're right sided, different, cool etc.

As for me, I stand in the middle, both are used equally and I wouldn't want it any other way.

I'm sure we all use both sides. You'd need to, in order to function in every day life.

However, I would think that one would tend to excel in one area more than others, or from their disposition or outlook on life be inclined to lean in one direction more, as gnome demonstrated and UM showed us.

Originally Posted by Solskye

I guess I'm living in la-la land alongside nina (dream come true, mind you)

So...when are you going to propose? *taps foot*

*gets down on one knee and opens a box which should've had a ring in it, but instead has some hits of acid and ecstasy*


You and me babe, and strawberry fields forever... Candy flip, and marry me?