Originally Posted by
Hukif
Man a lot of misconceptions.
First one, nobody gets SP while in REM. The name given is different, SP is only for when awake.
Second, since people dream naturally during NREM and don't move around and walk sleep, there is no reason to believe that having a lucid during such a stage will make you guys move.
Third, the late night cycles can be longer than an hour, so having a 1 hour lucid isn't that rare.
Then we have the fact that chaining cycles is posible which means its possible to have dreams that last over two hours, if people go ahead and get sleep deprived REM-rebound could make that go even higher and so on, it really depends on how people are dealing with the lucid.
And I mean, some newbies get very lucky so no reason to doubt it. And if you give someone the whole "importance because it could be a lie" they are more likely to lie again, just let them be and if they suddenly leave you will have your answer.