Does this Sound Like a Lucid Experience?

[s00p]

I can never control every aspect of my dreams, only the actions that I take. So it's pretty much like the real world only with fish that walk and wouldn't miind having me as a quick snack. My control over myself is amazing though. I can sometimes even endow myself with powers to do things. Usually my subconscious gives me a task (get people over glacier) and I have to find a way to solve it. In that scenario, if I concentrated really hard, I could move the pieces of the glacier. So, is it control or awareness that defines a lucid dream?

[onedayremains4]

being lucid means that you know you are dreaming. you can have a non lucid dream with amazing control, or a lucid dream with little or no control. so control, though a fun part of being lucid, does not itself make you lucid... that is unless you do something really amazing and then you're like "wait... i couldn't do that in real life"

[Leo Volont]

Originally posted by s00p I can never control every aspect of my dreams, only the actions that I take. So it's pretty much like the real world only with fish that walk and wouldn't miind having me as a quick snack. My control over myself is amazing though. I can sometimes even endow myself with powers to do things. Usually my subconscious gives me a task (get people over glacier) and I have to find a way to solve it. In that scenario, if I concentrated really hard, I could move the pieces of the glacier. So, is it control or awareness that defines a lucid dream? Lucid Dreaming is classically defined as only one thing -- knowing that one is dreaming when one is dreaming. "Control" was just some promotional hoopla that got added to the mix by authors and promoters of Weekend Seminars. Just take a look at some of these Essays which discuss the Lucid Dreaming State of the Art: http://www.sawka.com/spiritwatch/tableof.htm My first Dreaming Guru, the author of "Dream Power", Dr. Ann Faraday, was also a bit guilty of passing along the hype about absolute control being an element of Lucid Dreaming; but look at her most recent Essay, "The Selling of the Senoi" ( http://www.sawka.com/spiritwatch/selling.htm ) she discusses that the original research into Lucid Dreaming was exaggerated and even falsified in order to create a popularity buzz. Promises were made that were supported with purely fictional accounts. Everyone really needs to read through those essays and evaluate their own experiences (why does everyone but me have absolute control?) and understand that we all need to get away from the blurbs passed down by the profit-makers and begin to discuss what Lucid Dreaming really is.

[nerve]

awareness