Originally posted by Darkmatic
Ok , well ive never really thought about a God who was Limited in his actions . Although i dont believe in God , if i did it would make sense to me that God would have no limitations . Maybe he might some limitations , but they would pale in comparison to his power . For God to have created every thing in this universe and supposedly time and space also , then i would have to think that he had little if any limitation .
Please dont think that i think i know everything about a possible God , because i dont , i just draw conclusions from what i do know . And thats the reason i dont believe in god , because from what i actually know of him , which is nothing for sure , i can only think he doesnt even exist .
Anyway , back to your argument , the reason i said that he should not be limited to light was becasue i didnt quite understand what you meant by God is light . I suppose , if we were to see him all we would be seeing is light , but then you could argue that everything in the universe is simply light and nothing else .So i dont think thats how you meant it , perhaps you could elaborate on what 'God is light' means ...
The mistake you make is to come at God by way of Mathematical Philosophy. We are conditioned to think that way because the Atheist Establishment is careful to present only that View of God, since it is so easy to refute. And, yes, even the Bishops of the Catholic Church were guilty of outsourcing Theology to the influences of Greek Philosophy, but they were warned of their mistake by one no less great or inspired than Saint Bernard who insisted God be known entirely by His Revelation and then only analyzed far enough to know that Divinity is Mystery.
Then, even among the Thinkers of Theology, we have some silly thoughts. Think about it... if Time is Eternal, then there IS NO BEGINNING. Eternity is just that... Eternity... and Eternity would be open ended on both ends, no? The Hindus see it correctly. They don't fuss about any Beginning because there could never be a Beginning. They talk of a Cyclic Universe that had gone one forever. God does not fill the Role of Creator... the Universe IS and it always WAS. Why possit an unnecessary Creator. If one says that the Universe had to come from somewhere and so God is necessary as Creator, then it only pushes back the same question to Who created God. If something had to have already existed in the Beginning, then we can simply matters by saying that it was Matter which always existed. Consciousness and Life Organization, out of which God may have arisen, may well have followed after Matter and not necessarily come before it.
We may well discern the Development of God and Divinity by tracing the Moral Sensibilities of Humanity and examining the History of Civilization. God, in some sense, may be some Mathematical Absolute Purity, but as Einstein once said, a God that has no Providential Relationship to Humanity is a Useless and Irrelevent God. God is only God insofar as He is Providential. Yes, the Buddhists and some Hindus have gone as far as abandoning Humanity in order to connect to a Pure God of Virtually Nothing -- Nirvana. But that was several thousand years ago. Subsequently Religions have attempted more to combine Morality and Community along with the needs to have Transcendentally Ecstatic Experiences.
But going back to the original point, one who actually studies what actual Saints and Visionaries have experienced regarding God and Providence will be able to cite instance after instance of Divine Limitation and Struggle. The Philosopher and the Mathematician can guess, from within his Knowledge Vaccuum, from an Empiricism based on Zero Facts, that God has no Limitations. But the Saint, Visionary, Prophet or Oracle will see a much more complicated picture. Heck, just read the Bible and you will see it very clear and obvious that God has never had His Way. God has been successfully defied at practically every step. yes, God may have to be satisfied with some ultimate revenge upon those who have obstructed Him, but exercising Vindictive Counter-plans is hardly the Resort to which an Omnipotent God would have chosen as His Plan A. So, no, God is NOT Omnipotent. God is Struggling against Real Obstacles and Difficulties, just as we do.
Now, it is nice that Nirvanastarseed can be optimistic, but if suddenly everything were to go right for God, it would be the First Time.
It may take an Eternity for God to ever achieve His Perfection, and as I said before, Eternity will never happen. We can only hope that we can make things better.
|
|
Bookmarks