Would You Accept This?( Espeically Religious People)

[joey11223]

Hey guys, this is my first topic in the religious forum but it was something that has interested me recently. If next week an advanced alien race came to Earth and landed ships in every country to tell us that they were technically our Gods, would you accept it? Now i'm not saying they are truly Gods, though that depends on your definition of a God. They don't actually want us to worship them, they have come because they feel we are ready for the truth, and that truth is that they created us. Now i'm not saying they created the first single celled bacteria billions of years ago. They may not have even created the dinosaurs and early mammals. But there is a slight missing link between the humaniod Apes and us now. So i'm suggesting that either by making us in a lab or by genetic interference, they did make modern man. Obviously they didn't want to interfere to much with us, they mainly wanted to watch how a civilisation develops over time. But they slowly started introducing themselves to our timeline by various methods. One example would have been introducing the believe in Gods by speaking to some people and causing miracles in some areas. After time they sent down one of their own in humanoid form( Jesus), they went around preaching about God and doing various miracles to make sure we believed. They used religion in olden times because they felt we weren't ready to know and it would interfere to much in development, we would constantly ask them for things, which was proven by the amount of praying for things. But after 2000 years of Jesus they felt that we had modernised enough, we knew the answers to most questions and we had a great interest in our origins and meeting new races. So they decided we were ready to meet them. They explain everything, they explain why they made religion, they may even show us how theycan create life with what to them is simple machinery. So if this happens, will you accept it, they have shown us evidence to back up their claims, they show us each stage of our developement, they show us how they changed our DNA over time. They may even create a human before our eyes. So after all this, will you accept them as our creators, our Gods( if you are religious). Some would but some wouldn't, some may even try to fight them and destory them for "lieing". I was just wondering what your response would be? Especially strong religious people since they would not be your vision of what God would be, since they are just another very advanced race, after all we may create lifeforms in the future.

[Universal Mind]

I would accept them as our creators if they could really prove it, and I would majorly thank them. But if they wanted me to start worshipping them, I would see them as emotionally primitive. They wouldn't get worship out of me. Nothing that asks to be worshipped is worthy of being worshipped.

[Indecent Exposure]

I would accept them as our creators if they could really prove it, and I would majorly thank them. But if they wanted me to start worshipping them, I would see them as emotionally primitive. They wouldn't get worship out of me. Nothing that asks to be worshipped is worthy of being worshipped. [/b] Same really, although I'd shorten that alst sentence to.. "Nothing is worthy of worship" Imran

[Universal Mind]

"Nothing is worthy of worship" [/b] I agree with that. Nothing that asks to be worshipped is worthy of being worshipped, and nothing that never asks to be worshipped is anything there is any point in worshipping. So nothing is worthy of being worshipped.

[joey11223]

Yes im not really saying we must worship them, they did that in the past to help guide us, but now they dont ask it of us. I would like some religious responses, i mean technically they are your God, but would you accept them, afterall they are just another race, not some omnipotent being. Maybe one day we will actually be able to do this with other races, would that make us Gods?

[Universal Mind]

Yes im not really saying we must worship them, they did that in the past to help guide us, but now they dont ask it of us. I would like some religious responses, i mean technically they are your God, but would you accept them, afterall they are just another race, not some omnipotent being. Maybe one day we will actually be able to do this with other races, would that make us Gods? [/b] It doesn't make them gods. A farmer is not automatically the god of his vegetables.

[juroara]

I wouldnt care what the aliens would have to say, since I do not take the bible literally as meaning God sculpted us out of his own hands. In this scenario God created the natural laws that biology of any form or kind would have to adhere to. All living substance is Gods substance. I concider angels to be intelligent beings, and I would not be surprised if they were intelligent enough to design life forms.

[joey11223]

It doesn't make them gods. A farmer is not automatically the god of his vegetables. [/b] Ah but that depends on your definition, and technically its not the same. Farmers didnt create seeds, they planted them, but lets say farmers create seeds with some experiment. Oks so they have created a new type of crop, lets just say its bright purple and 2 metres tall( we have arms and legs and organs, we would be like the seeds). So if the plants grown from those seeds could think, then why isnt the farmers there Gid? I mean he created life from nothing, he can destory life, he can change it, he can do tiny little things like spraying the crops with pesticides, which dramatically change existance for the crops. So if your definition of a God is a creator of life, then the farmer is a god to his crops. But i am not saying the Aliens want us to pray to them as Gods, they only used that when we were less developed as a way of slowly introducing themselves into our primitive society and laying dwon laws in way we would understand. So since they created us and we are saying they invented the first religion on Earth, which we branched off from. They could be seen as God.

[Neruo]

An 'Alien'-scenario is always very interesting, because it would totally destroy some 'we are so special and god make us like him' pillars of religion. I could accept that aliens just created us for fun or research or something. I do find it unlikely however.

[Merlin38]

If aliens were actually our creators, I would treat them in the same way that I understand God. They are entities from which we can learn valuable lessons to further our own purposes.

[Jeremysr]

They'd have to prove that they were not Satan deceiving us. Then they'd have to explain all the things that made me sure of God's existence. Then I would reluctantly not believe in what I do anymore, but still live the same way as a christian (be centered on others instead of self-centered.) But that's hardly a question, it's impossible to me (that's why I didn't post here at first.)

[tekdawg]

I'd say they would have to had created the universe to be a GOD. And I don't think a GOD would need a spaceship to get to Earth.

[taihen]

Yep, the concept of a god requires some spiritual or supernatural element. If aliens did create us etc. etc., then we would see them as logical creators and not as gods.

[Talon]

An 'Alien'-scenario is always very interesting, because it would totally destroy some 'we are so special and god make us like him' pillars of religion. [/b] Your correct that it would totally destroy some religions... actually most. I think that Christianity would be the most destroyed and questionable. A man was hung on a cross and killed, and three days later was seen alive and acsended into the "heavens". There are a lot of factors that are detrimental to most religions that are over-looked. As well as a lot of things that have been found to prove certian things about some religions. The most debateable which has always been , Christianity. Hell, finding the body of Christ would be detrimental and therefore cause an uprising of supposed hypocrites. I think that if this happened and these aliens came down, I would not accept them as a "god", but I could accept the fact that we were in essence an experiment. But whose saying that they evolved the same way we did and was actually as curious as us as humans are. I think I'm going to shut up now lol. Point being is there is still a lot of factors to take in. Nice post!

[tekdawg]

This is hilarious, people who don't believe in a creator trying to use aliens to debunk religion. This is an all time low.

[Talon]

This is hilarious, people who don't believe in a creator trying to use aliens to debunk religion. This is an all time low. [/b] No one is trying to debunk religion... It's a good point. Besides, it's more probable aliens are out there reather than not.

[taihen]

Oh dear, this is an all time low then? I could point out many lows the Christians have stooped to to make excuses for stupidities in the bible, but that would be cruel and just make you even more insecure. No one is debunking religion, its a HYPOTHETICAL ARGUMENT.

[Talon]

Oh dear, this is an all time low then? I could point out many lows the Christians have stooped to to make excuses for stupidities in the bible, but that would be cruel and just make you even more insecure. No one is debunking religion, its a HYPOTHETICAL ARGUMENT. [/b] Ha ha brings a thought to mind and this is directed to no one just funny for people who arent Christians: It's your hell, go burn in it. This was said to my uncle who was preaching to me.

[tekdawg]

Who mentioned Christians? I sure didn't. Why do you 2 feel the need to attack Christians? The first mention of anything Christian was the 1st post, he mentioned Jesus as a time reference. Then Jeremysr was the first one to mention the word Christian but it was in a descriptive sense. Just read the bold text, he clearly use it as a description for himself while answering the question put forth by joey11223. He didn't use it as a means to discredit the topic. Post #11 They'd have to prove that they were not Satan deceiving us. Then they'd have to explain all the things that made me sure of God's existence. Then I would reluctantly not believe in what I do anymore, but still live the same way as a christian (be centered on others instead of self-centered.) But that's hardly a question, it's impossible to me (that's why I didn't post here at first.) [/b] However 3 posts after Jeremysr's post Talon was the first one to use Christians as the object of his post. Post #14 Your correct that it would totally destroy some religions... actually most. I think that Christianity would be the most destroyed and questionable. A man was hung on a cross and killed, and three days later was seen alive and acsended into the "heavens". There are a lot of factors that are detrimental to most religions that are over-looked. As well as a lot of things that have been found to prove certian things about some religions. The most debateable which has always been , Christianity. Hell, finding the body of Christ would be detrimental and therefore cause an uprising of supposed hypocrites. I think that if this happened and these aliens came down, I would not accept them as a "god", but I could accept the fact that we were in essence an experiment. But whose saying that they evolved the same way we did and was actually as curious as us as humans are. I think I'm going to shut up now lol. Point being is there is still a lot of factors to take in. Nice post! [/b] Then taihen assumed I was Christian or something and used Christians as the object of her post. Post #17 Oh dear, this is an all time low then? I could point out many lows the Christians have stooped to to make excuses for stupidities in the bible, but that would be cruel and just make you even more insecure. No one is debunking religion, its a HYPOTHETICAL ARGUMENT. [/b] You should re-read your own post before attacking something for no reason.

[joey11223]

Ha ha brings a thought to mind and this is directed to no one just funny for people who arent Christians: It's your hell, go burn in it. This was said to my uncle who was preaching to me. [/b] you confuse me, so you are saying this wasn't targeted at christians and you were joking when you said it was right? " this is directed to no one" is what you are saying, which is correct , glad we got that over with. I bet if they came it would start off a new religion, or totally boost that science religion, canna remember the name of it right now.. Eh i'd just be thankful they did make me and aslong as they had a cool name like: Goa'uld, Scrin, Seraphim, Aeon, Asgard, etc. Then i'd think they were pretty cool and totally invite them round for TV and beers . Though their pad would probably be way cooler, then HD HD TV :yumdumdoodledum:. oh and to your uncle, yeah i' ll see you there you obviouslty hate filled sinner , if he wants to meet me, tell him to meet by the pool of J2O( organe and passion fruit,duh) on the lesbian island( yes part of that was from scrubs)!!

[Neruo]

This is hilarious, people who don't believe in a creator trying to use aliens to debunk religion. This is an all time low. [/b] Explain why (the Christian) god would create aliens. And why he kept it a little seeecret ^____^

[joey11223]

Explain why (the Christian) god would create aliens. And why he kept it a little seeecret ^____^ [/b] thats not what he's saying, he is saying the thought of aliens creating us is ridiculous, although itys interesting that we are quite close to making robots with working AI's, so we have made robotic life already. and with genetic engineering, in a few thousand years we will probably be creating life of our own to study. It is interesting tthat the Bible mentions no other worlds though, i'll grant you that. Of oucrse the main response to this is that the Bible was written for its time period... Which means either we need the bible 2.0( which Jesus could have come and given to us in the yr 2000) or that the Bible is just to outdated to be used when argueing the case of new scientific discoveries.

[Neruo]

thats not what he's saying, he is saying the thought of aliens creating us is ridiculous, .[/b] You sure? He did make that remark after I said Aliens would undermine religion. I don't think he was talking about the Aliens-made-us-hypothesis. Which means either we need the bible 2.0( which Jesus could have come and given to us in the yr 2000) or that the Bible is just to outdated to be used when argueing the case of new scientific discoveries. [/b] Oh yeah, the bible should be updated if Aliens come... WHY THE HELL don't they update it now? It has been done at the conference of niceae... Twice if I remember. Since the bible is all true, god had time to let people edit the bible back then, but he doesn't have had the time since then? Not like ethically and in many other ways the world have Changed GREATLY now? Aliens would be a nice bonus of time and (historical) knowledge debunking the bible and religion.

[Drk Pwnr]

To the original question of the topic, I wouldn't accept right away. I would want proof. For all we know, it could be a practical joke on us and our 'religion'. Actually, once humanity has the technology, I would LOVE to go around to random alien civilizations with religions and say I'm god

[Talon]

Let me just clarify a couple things. I was not attacking anyone, or any religion. As I said, I was raised Christian, Baptist as a matter of fact. I respect teh fact that you and others are christians and I refuse to hold that against anyone. I was trying to get a point across that our "alien creators" could destroy some religions. The biggest being Christianity. That was the point that I was tring to get across. When I said, "It's your hell, go burn in it.", I was referring to a conversation that I was having with my uncle, a pastor. He was criticizing me and we were arguing a few points in the Bible, Christianity vs. Wiccanism. It was not intended to offend but was said as a joke. Because he tells me all the time that I am going to hell. Sorry if I offended, but PLEASE be sure that it was unintentional.