Originally Posted by Jdog
beliving in god is a win win situation. if you belive in a god and go to church or some form of worship for an hour every sunday and there is a god you get in to heaven and win. if there isnt a god you lose and hour of every sunday which you would have wasted anyway but you dont realy lose anything. so why claim to be an atheist when there is a posibility that a god exists?
theres just no logic in not beliving in a god.
If there is a God, he is too big for one religion. How do you choose which to follow? The most common answer would be the biggest, easiest, and most rewarding. Welcome to Christianity.
If there was only one religion, or all religions were less different, and the religions weren't so contradictory, this theory could hold true. Since that is not the case, it is more logical to take a neutral or an unbiased spiritual view, as in Deism which follows no religion yet still believes in a God. This is basically a Theist/Agnostic hybrid.
The reason that people would choose to be an Atheist, aside from the above, is both that religions are highly illogical / nonsensical, and because of the different advances in science that coincide with Theist views. Evolution completely contradict the Gospel. There is the Theistic Evolution theory that God created evolution, but that is still coinciding with the Gospel and was only created to appease some concerned people.
Overall, when you put your faith in a religion, you put your faith in people. It wasn't God that wrote the Bible, it was people. God didn't translate the Bible from Koptic to Hebrew to Greek to Latin to English, people did. God didn't tell you how to interpret certain controversial topics in the Bible, people did. God didn't choose what to leave out and keep in the Bible in the 4th Century, people did. There were originally over 30 Gospels, but the church chose only to keep Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John because they were the most well known at the time and because the others could contradict, only showing the flaws of emotions in humans in some of the most influential of religious icons.
So, while it is debatable whether belief in God is logical, it is not very logical at all to believe in a religion.
Originally Posted by Jdog
i imagine if a god did exist then he would be much more impressed with my "lip sevice" then you total deniance.
"If God were alive today, he'd be an Atheist." - Somebody I forgot
If there is a God who is omniscient and omnipotent, he would clearly see through the fog of lies and deceit provided by the church. For a God who is all-loving, omnipotent, and omniscient, allowing flawed humans to run a campaign that regulates his existence down to every basic section of human life is unreasonable on the highest of standards.
Originally Posted by Jdog
i came up with the "most religious folks are happier than atheists" from my general experience in life. i have both atheist and religious friends, and most of the time those religious friends are the ones who seem to be quite happy with what they have, rather than always searching for something more.
I actually find the opposite in most cases. Nearly all of the strongly religious people I know are very uptight and are too concerned about something or another to have as much fun as they could have. The few Agnostics and Atheists that I know, however, don't care about having to keep up with a religious agenda, and also aren't being told so many things by a church that their heads are on the verge of explosion. This leaves them as very very fun people.
Originally Posted by Semper Erato
This is a pugnatious thread. I'm a Christian, I believe in God, and I do not belive that atheism is the right path to follow, but if you are trying to convince the other side that they're wrong, this isn't the way to go about it.
That said, I can't help but express my opinion on the subject.
OK, on the side of Jdog, it's like the argument that one of the philosophers from the Age of Reason in Europe made--I cannot remember for the life of me which one it was, perhaps Kant or Hegel--basically that God may or may not exist, but it would be better to believe and be proven wrong after death than to not believe and find that he does exist. Like so many things in life, one can never be sure.
I think it may have been Pascal. Not exactly sure, but that sounds right.
Originally Posted by Semper Erato
Another point to consider is that there are different forms and divisions of Christianity; not all Christians (laypeople or otherwise) believe that gays will go to hell. Not all Christians believe that people who do not go to church will go to hell. As with any other group, stereotypes do not accurately describe every Christian. There are churches that preach fire and brimstone every Sunday (and Wednesday), and I have seen at least one, but my church isn't like that and it isn't the only one.
Only the lesser of two evils. Yes, the fire and brimstone church is pretty bad. When I was very young at a church camp some preacher randomly started preaching like that and it scared the shit out of me. Scare tactics as an attempt to convert. The Gospel still says those things though, and many people take them literally. Should I be stoned because I didn't go to church today? You may say no because you are slightly more logical than other Christians, but I guarantee you that some would say yes. It's great when you only see the best side of things.
Originally Posted by Semper Erato
Last, and maybe most important, is that most churches teach that God forgives, the Puritans being the only exception that comes to mind at the moment. So yes, people aren't perfect, but that's why Christians repent for their sins, so they can be forgiven. It doesn't mean that you can't try to be better, but people make mistakes.
If God forgives, truly, there would be no need for Hell. An all-forgiving God as Christians preach would not send anybody to Hell. Even if they cursed Jesus' name while killing and raping babies.
Originally Posted by Semper Erato
On the other hand, I can sympathize with those who do not believe in a Christian God or God of any sort. I went through a period of my life when I didn't believe. The most pressing question for me was, "If God loves us, why do we suffer?" Indeed there is suffering in the world, too much for a single person to wrap their head around. Why would God allow this?
Another reason people don't believe is that it isn't practical. There are so many other things one could do during that 1-3 hours spent at church every Sunday.
The time spent isn't as impractical as the things spent in those hours and the resulting person afterwards.
Originally Posted by Semper Erato
The last is another pressing matter: Why would a God who loves all send so many people to hell? Gays, people who have sex outside of marriage, atheists... There seems to be no end to the possibilities of people not going to heaven, at least according to the teachings of men.
Hey, I said that.
Originally Posted by Semper Erato
Now I have my philosophy...or theology... Call me a heretic for some of these things, but I don't care. Excommunicate me.
1. The Bible is not infalible; it was written by human hand, and man is not infalible, so neither is his writing. Furthermore, many things are lost or distorted in translation.
2. The Bible shouldn't be taken word for word. Many of the things it says pertain to the times, such as restrictions on the power of women.
3. God forgives, so if you do something wrong and you regret it, you can ask for forgiveness and you will recieve it. I'm still debating myself in the case of something looked down upon but not regretted by the "guilty" party.
4. God appears to everyone as he will most readily accept him. Every religion has a savior and a moral code, most setting laws against acts of cruelty or waste. Again, I'm still debating myself a little, but I don't believe that God would send a person to hell simply for not being taught about Jesus.
5. As to why there is so much suffering, I believe that God proides strength to get through situations. We also have loved ones. Life is a trial, a test, if you will, and the reward for getting through it is eternal paradise. The Church is one community that helps to meet that end; it makes life easier when you can relate to others, unify and support one another and seek support from God.
My belief system is a work in progress; I don't think God can ever be fully understood, which is where faith comes in. If you don't want to believe, no one can make you. You just have to decide what is most important to you. I just think that an atheist's path is a cold and lonely one, with no hope for something better. That's one of the reasons why people do believe; sometimes they have to to keep going.
Rant's over, I promise. Sorry I overdid it.
You are a very logical, smart person I see. Many aspects of your beliefs are very logical, and the first steps I started making to becoming Deist, then Agnostic. Not saying that you should, though. See where everything leads you. You're definitely one of the most reasonable Christians I've seen in a long time.
|
|
Bookmarks