Great idea, it's something I wonder about a lot too, whether some lucids are actually just dreams of lucidity. That's one of the reasons I've always been reluctant to "plan" an LD before going to sleep, I keep thinking to myself: "If I'm actually conscious in the dream, why would I need to have a whole plan ready? Maybe planning only makes you have a simulated lucid dream where you attempt what you were intent on doing, which is why many people would get 'results'."

Anyways, I'm in. I guess I'd rather be part of the control group, although I wouldn't mind being in the experimental one that much if needed. As a sidenote, the reality check I usually use is the nose plug and breathing one; I think that could be a decent one to choose.

Hope we get some more people and interesting results!