 Originally Posted by cmind
Oh I didn't realize you've been trying for so long. Usually people come on this forum after failing a WILD just once and say they don't get it.
I think your problem is that you've been reading too much crap about lucid dreaming. A lot of stuff people say (and write in books) is just crap. There isn't a better word for it. And when you fill your mind with all the crap about dream yoga, and mantras, and stuff like that, you will fail. Because that stuff doesn't actually do anything.
I forget the scientific term for this, but it's when you do an action in conjunction with another action and you incorrectly attribute the results to the wrong action. So, say I blink 3 times every time I start my car. And I never try starting my car without blinking 3 times. I may start believing that to start a car, one must insert the key and blink 3 times. See where I'm going with this? Just because people do dream yoga, that doesn't mean the dream yoga did dick all in getting them into lucid dreams.
This also explains why lucid dreams come easier for you after "slacking". Because the "slacking" was allowing the useless crap to leave your mind, and the intuition took over.
You need to FORGET everything you think you know about lucid dreams, especially the mystical crap. Lucid dreaming is a physiological process. Beliefs, mantras, magical spells, etc. will not help you. But they WILL hinder you. And I do include complicated "techniques" as magical spells. Because that's exactly what they are -- spells. They're recipes that you blindly follow without truly understanding the underlying principles, if there are any.
Remember...lucid dreaming is a physiological process. Do you need to follow a set of instructions to ride a bike? No, you just know. If you need instructions to ride a bike, you can't ride a bike. Same thing goes for lucid dreaming. If you need to remember instructions, you won't be able to do it.
I'm rambling.
lol right on man. i can't say i fully agree with you but your feedback is helpful and appreciated! basically nine years ago i bought exploring the world of lucid dreaming by stephen laberge (all science, even explaining the science behind some of the "magic" stuff. probably the best and most well known book on the topic) and had pretty good success with MILD and a few other techniques in it. then over the years i've gone back and forth between practicing really hard to slacking and sometimes quitting completely. usually i pick up EWLD and re read it and have success again. instead recently i picked up a book on dream yoga and had zero success. so simplify is what you're saying basically?
you might be on to something because every time i've read EWLD and worked from it i've had fair success. and literally every other source has almost always failed me! i don't believe in the magic parts at all of dream yoga or whatever else. i've always read about them and tried to pick out the kernels of logical lucid dreaming technique. like in dream yoga you're supposed to pray to your "guru" or if you don't have one pick an ancient deity and pray to them... ooookaaaay... so what i took from that is a strong driving state of mind that is focused on the goal should do the trick. i'm not going to just blindly say "okie dokey i'll pray to random gods to lucid dream! perfect!" but i will try to find the real applicable practices inside these kind of "out there" practices.
other than that the dream yoga practice was telling yourself you are dreaming alllllllllll day long. so theoretically when dreaming you say the same thing out of habit and it's true! also there are things like falling asleep while imagining a glowing clear tibetan letter "A" in front of a lotus flower on your throat chakra. now i read this and see that it's basically a WILD technique, visualizing such an intricate thing keeps the mind somewhat alert as you fall asleep and so you should be able to retain the right amount of consciousness to become lucid. whereas the book i read this in gave magical reasons for this working and how the chakra links the energy body to the regular body blah blah blah and how it would effect dreaming i just picked out the real provable stuff. however i think you do have a valid point in that it's best to stick to one very scientific, down to earth approach that keeps it simple and requires no re thinking to make it so.
the bicycle example is a good one. a few tips and a straightforward approach and you should be riding in no time. but spin a bunch of crazy rules, methods, and reasons that aren't logical into it and you'll be scratching your head. stephen laberge actually says in the book that he had his first lucid dream, having previously only had them as a kid, after trying tibetan dream yoga as taught to him by a yogi! after this he came to the conclusion that he should take a more scientific approach but he still includes the applicable dream yoga techniques in his book. so there's some truth and logic to it but, like stephen laberge, i think going in the more scientific direction is the right way to go.
i don't think it's impossible that all the dream yoga and other stuff is real. it's possible that there's all this magical stuff and what not but that we just don't have the right equipment to study it yet. three hundred years ago the idea that we are all made of cells and that electricity runs through our bodies was unknown and if someone said it people would have said it was hocus pocus non sense but here we are. but without proof in this modern age i keep myself grounded in science and healthy skepticism. this doesn't mean i don't appreciate it though and i think there's a lot of good stuff to be extracted from that type of thing that will fit right in with the scientific stuff we love so dearly all in all in my opinion the most sound approach to lucid dreaming is the kind of stuff that is sound, scientific, and provable.
|
|
Bookmarks