Originally posted by YourTheManNowDog
well in my case i was originally only meaning that, \" dissociated states where ones consciousness is perceived to be independant of the body\"....where you appear to be somewhere else interacting somewhere else while your body lays sleeping or in some trance state......
Yes, that's excellent! Thank you very much, that was explained very clearly and directly. And it is simple and inclusive... not attached to any particular ontology and open to investigation.
It makes no assumptions on whether one's consciousness actually is independent of the body, just that it looks like it could be. Also, it makes no assumptions on whether this a sickness.
"Dissociation" means something very different in psychiatry and, should we continue to use this word, the meanings must not be confused. It refers to a psychological defense mechanism where traumatic thoughts, feelings, or sensations are separated from the psyche, like blocking out an experience of child abuse. This is why I wanted your statement to be very clear, because I'd think many psychiatrists are tempted to relate LDs closely with an obsession with fantasy and thus, pathology.
I do not think daydreaming can be properly classed as a dissociated state under your definition. In daydreams we may be distracted from reality, but it never appears that our consciousness is independent of the body.
Psychosis, on the other hand, includes a degenerating contact with reality, and could therefore include your definition. However, that does not mean your definition is dependent on psychiatry and thus, it is not psychotic in nature.
So, I'm glad that neither daydreaming nor psychosis are dissociated states under your definition, because those are not the focus of our study.
I think I'm going to be thinking about this for a while, and I'll try to incorporate it into my studies. Since this is theory very early in development, I'm going to continue referring to our phenomena under question as LDs (or dreams proper, if the dreamer does not know he or she is dreaming).
|
|
Bookmarks