Hey there,
Didnt mean to amply that language is the only way to recognise a dream. In fact, I don't even think language is a way to recognise a dream at all.
What language does do, is expand our consciousness. Not because it is language, but because it allows us to get more of a grip on the world, order it, structure it, symbolise new concepts. That's the consciousness-expanding quality of any symbolic system, of which language is simply the one most known to us.
Can animals do this? I think yes, to a degree, so I'm inclined to agree with you, to a degree. We certainly know cats and dogs and other animals can learn, which is more then a simple 'reaction' to an event, and would in fact require some sort of low level consciousness, in my mind.
Would an animal know the difference between waking and dreaming? Maybe. More likely, in my mind, an animal would be very unlikely to even remember its dreams, since the act of remembering requires a great deal of consciousness. Most humans don't really remember their dreams neither, why would we expect animals to do better on that aspect. They're likely less conscious overall then we are, therefor even less likely to even remember their dreams. Sure, they do dream, but when they wake up... do they have any inclination that they dreamed at all?
Any sort of dream-skill, be it recall, lucidity, dreamcontrol, all seems to require a certain degree of 'heightened consciousness'. We have that 'heigthened consciousness' through the symbolic system we deviced to structure the world around us (language, in our case). Assuming animals do not have this to the same degree that we do, we can therefor also assume that they'd be less likely to remember their dreams, to control their dreams, and far less likely to be lucid.
Now flipping this around, we go by the assumption that dreaming and sleeping is a state of reduced consciousness for us. A state where our consciousness is far less active and far less prevalent. Now if we assume that animals are in general less conscious then we are, we could make the hypothesis that animals would go through life pretty much like we go through dreams (though perhaps low level lucid dreams would compare better, as, by your own example, animals can learn, which does require a fair amount of consciousness).
-Redrivertears-
|
|
Bookmarks