I voted yes. It saved more lives than it ended. |
|
The atomic bombs in Japan prevented the inevitable invasion and take-over of Japan. Do you think that more than 200,000 deaths (the amount of deaths caused by the bombs) would have occured in the invasion of Japan. |
|
I voted yes. It saved more lives than it ended. |
|
Adopted Megabenman although he disappeared a while ago.
Alright, so far thats 3 to 0. KEEP IT UP!!!! |
|
Wouldn't a better idea be, to get one of the mods to split off the Hiro/Naga discussion from the Iraq thread, rather than to make a wholly new thread? |
|
50 : 50!!!!!!!!! 3;!!!!!!!! |
|
aite, keep it up. |
|
I voted no. There were a lot of deaths in Europe but Japan's a lot smaller isn't it?! Maybe less people died than would have but to me saying yes is condoning it. I feel sorry for the pilots who dropped it, having all those deaths on your hands...maybe they're heroes to some...I don't look on them badly, just feel sorry for them. I wonder how they feel about it now. |
|
I voted no because an invasion of Japan was not necessary, so it becomes irrelevant whether it would have killed more to invade than the bombs killed. Continuation of the blockade and willingness to accept a conditional surrender (like allowing the emperor to remain in power) would have been possible with far fewer casualties. |
|
[23:17:23] <+Kaniaz> "You think I want to look like Leo Volont? Don't you dare"
I voted no because for one Truman decided to drop the A - Bomb to deter away from a costly US invasion which didn't matter because Soviet Union began an invasion a few days after the Hiroshima bombing, not because of the atomic bombs themselves. This was just the U.S way of trying to impress the Soviet Union Thus kick Starting the Cold War. |
|
I said no for the same reasons exactly as Ne-yo and Tsen. yah me too, ive always thought this was quite a big reason for the start of the cold war. |
|
Yup, I too feel that dropping the bombs was a big factor in the start of the Cold War. |
|
[23:17:23] <+Kaniaz> "You think I want to look like Leo Volont? Don't you dare"
oh yea, man the dropping of the a bomb started the cold war. |
|
You seem to have an extreme case of selective hearing. |
|
[23:17:23] <+Kaniaz> "You think I want to look like Leo Volont? Don't you dare"
Aha, shows how much you know about Japan. |
|
No they weren't. Japan didn't have the industrial resources needed to support their rapidly growing and industrializing nation. |
|
[23:17:23] <+Kaniaz> "You think I want to look like Leo Volont? Don't you dare"
Once again, your ignorance of japanese history and culture shows |
|
|
|
Hominus, you really are being an idiot. |
|
[23:17:23] <+Kaniaz> "You think I want to look like Leo Volont? Don't you dare"
they were looking to dominate asia, but their history as an isolationist country would have enabled them to survive. |
|
Survive, perhaps, but just barely. It would be sufficient pressure to force them to surrender--they were already bordering on surrender, and had made a few attempts at seeking acceptable terms. |
|
[23:17:23] <+Kaniaz> "You think I want to look like Leo Volont? Don't you dare"
What you know about Japan is quite questionable Hominus. how do you figure that Japan was an isolationist during WW2? If my history on Japan serves me right the Japanese were not isolationist during the 2nd world war. Gunboat Diplomacy was forced upon Japan in 1854 and forcing the country out of Isolationism. |
|
No. |
|
yes and no |
|
you can't do that on the internet!.... wait yes you can do it again!
The dropping of the atomic bombs was the right choice. |
|
How do you know you are not dreaming right now?
Bookmarks