 Originally Posted by Kaitakaro
The believe that the universe was created alone ,from a huge explosion out of nothing and some very convenient natural laws is also a very absurd claim...
I can understand that heavy exposure to Abraham religion madness can make one inclined to Atheism, but Atheism is not science its also a religious believe...
You are making the same mistake a majority of theists (and some supposed atheists) make about Atheism. I get where you are coming from when you say it's a "religious" belief, but that right there illustrates the issue here. Atheism is not a belief about anything. Atheism does not claim that God or gods do not exist. Atheism is a lack of belief in a God or gods because the scientific evidence we have doesn't support the belief that a god or many gods exist. Atheism can't be a religious belief, because it isn't a belief it all, it is specifically the lack of a belief.
Some atheists take things a step too far and wind up asserting that god or gods do not or cannot exist, and some atheists do wind up kind of forming communities that suggest that atheism is almost like a form of religion, despite it being devoid of any of the qualities that make religions... religions. It's therefore easy for people to mistakenly believe that atheism itself is a "religion", that it's like a religion, or that it's at the very least a religious belief, because it is a belief that concerns a religious topic. However, as I've already stated, these are strawman representations of atheism/atheists. Atheism by definition is a lack of a belief in god or gods. And I know I sound like a broken record by now, but it is not a belief that god or gods don't exist. There is definite nuance in my last two statements. At first glance it can be difficult to understand just how nuanced they are, but it's enough to render most of the ideas that theists have and posit about atheists into nothing more than strawmen, at best. It's indicative of a flawed understanding of what atheism is from the get-go, and that understanding has to be corrected before any meaningful discussion can happen on the subject.
On the topic of the Big Bang being equally absurd... it actually has evidence supporting it. That being said, even if it is a far-fetched idea, it is not even close as being the same level of absurdity as the gods presented in the world's various religions. One idea has a lot more going for it, and it doesn't have a lot more going for it simply because a lot of people choose to believe it. There is at least some level of empirical evidence and critical thought that has gone into the idea. If I had to pick, it would easily be the theory I would go with (the other theories being the various organized religions around the world). To act like somebody is foolish for arriving at this decision because it's also an absurd idea is ignoring the very values we hold when it comes to good decision making. If you really believe that picking something that makes you feel better is a better criterion for decision making then I have to question whether somebody who uses the same criteria in decision making as you should be considered qualified to hold a political office of any kind, or be any kind of leader in society. I wouldn't really go that far, but the fact that you think that the various religions around the world are equally as absurd as the Big Bang Theory, or rather that any of the religions could possibly be less absurd (because to do so means you don't base your decisions on evidence or logical reasoning) is honestly disheartening and a bit... scary. Scary isn't quite the right word, but I can't find one that's better.
 Originally Posted by lidybug
The truth is you are love it is the core of your being.
I really, really don't like such terribly ambiguous and nigh meaningless statements. Can you please explain to me what you mean about people being love, and love is the core of one's being? I've heard people say things like "life is love, everything is love" before, but at most it comes across as incredibly shallow emotional spiritual babble. What is the statement even supposed to mean? How can I take it seriously? From all of my experiences in life, I know for a fact that love was not my default state of being. That is to say, I was not born being a loving being. Children are incredibly cruel and borderline evil. They can be incredibly violent, and one could even go as far as to say they are capable of torture in the right situation. They are some of the most monstrous bullies you could even encounter. The idea that children are pure and innocent has never made sense to me. They are demonstrably some of the most psychopathic, vicious, and cold-hearted beings out there, next to adults who possess the same negative traits. Eventually they are taught kindness, to behave appropriately, to care for one another, to experience love, and to do the right thing.
So, it wouldn't be fair to say we are born as loving beings, so how can we say that love is at the core of one's being (let alone that we are love)? How can we say that life is love, and that everything is love? It's a gross idealization of reality, and at best highly wishful thinking. Reality is so much more complicated than that--your statement is just... meaningless. What's more, it completely baffles me. What implications does love being the core of our being have on humanity and on individual people? What purpose does the statement have? What idea are you really trying to get across? What does it mean in grand scheme of things? Are you just trying to say that, indirectly it means God is part of us, or that we are a part of God? That last bit is about the only idea I could come up with, and if it's what you were meaning to say, why not actually say that instead?
I don't mean to sound so hostile or negative, but it's kind of a pet-peeve/annoyance when people make statements that you can tell they believe are profound and meaningful--something really worth saying--but in reality it is a generally bland and relatively meaningless statement. It means about as much to me as saying that, "God's light is truth", or some other such nonsense. What is that even trying to say?
|
|
Bookmarks