It is possible to dream about being lucid. I will normally think 'I am lucid so I can do this or that.' But that is easily taken away because I didn't really know what lucid meant.And a leprechaun stole my lucidity. Literally that is what he told me.

But, especially the eye thing, sounds like you had a non vivid lucid. It happens. Kind of sucks, but you need to rejoice for even that.

Don't try to fix your eye or you could wake up. Just try to realize the truth.