Oooookay....
Pfeh..
This thread took an odd turn while I was out. Most of the legal things considering pot smoking and other things are beyond my pay grade and I will not comment most of them, but because I have condemned my life to art of fighting I will reply to those things I find odd.
Originally Posted by Ne-yo
I know a little. I've practiced the art of Changquan Wushu since I was 5 years of age. I also practice Wu/Hao Taijiquan as well as Yang style. My Ojisan was also my sensei who has taught me Ryukyu Kobujutsu which training was focused primarily on styles of bo efficiency. I do not use Wushu for fighting I use it to encompass and focus the 3 internal and external harmonies and ki o awasu.
I have also studied Taijiquan a bit ( just for the short 24 movements) and stolen few things from Wing Chuan to our own style. If I recall right, Kobujutsu is a japanese style of using weapons like bo, tonfa and such? Or am I completely wrong?
Chinese martial arts ( which are referred as wushu as whole, if I am right.) span for thousands of years and I can give them a credit from that. Sadly, there are many hundreds of individual styles which I cannot keep clear track how they operate. One thing I can tell for certain is that I have never lost a fight to a wushu/kung fu practicioner and they never fight as they train. This is the main thing that leads me to believe their training is more spiritually aligned instead of functioning techniques. It is also the reason why I don't see any need to train them much or have a same amount of respect as I have for other styles. Only thing that chinese martial arts have developed above all else is the handwork on the close distance which is referred as sticky hands by westerners. I am not aware what is the real, chinese name for that. For wushu competitions, it seems that appearances are respected more than strength. Nice shows they do, but that is all about it. Circus shows are better in that respect.
Originally Posted by Ne-yo
True Wushu incorporates focus on self-control and self-discipline. You're not a true martial artist. I think you're a fraud to be honest.
This is the common argument with budo/wushu practicioners. I can understand this in its way, because nowadays many jutsu's have become do's and have embraced the philosophy of peace. I, however, see no reason why you couldn't do something else if your goal is a peace of mind and inner tranquility. You could paint, jog, play volleyball or play guitar. These are true arts of peace. I accept many of budos ideas like conquering yourself, because it is pretty much true. We are own worst enemies in a fight. We make it hard for ourselves. But I am also something you'd like to call perhaps a pure martial artist. I revere and respect the ability, not intention. I have been sickened many times before by people who defile ( in my point of view) martial arts by teaching non-functioning, self-dangering unrealistic shit as martial arts. They just exploit peoples inner fear of conflict and uncertainty to either make money or just influence them and get respect. How I teach is the sensible approach for my students. I don't promote violence, but I show them ways to do violent things if there ever arises a need to in order to protect the things you seem worth it. Without any mystical terms or concepts/stories. Only stories I tell them are about real life and situations there are out there.
As general note, I don't want to construct a true view from a persons martial art skills via internet. Only way I know how is to fight them and see their fighting potential myself. Here it is all talk. Of course, I try also to bring points that likely minded martial artists understand to promote my own view of the arts I practice and share my experience. For the record, based of what I have discussed with ninja in the past I would like to visit and spar him sometime. I am just pretty much stuck here at the moment, but if I come near where he lives, I would like that very much.
Originally Posted by Ne-yo
Doing drugs and true arts of Wushu does not mix. Like I said I believe you are fraud. True athletes do not take part in the use of marijuana. How can you call yourself an instructor of Martial Arts and you're smoking weed? What is wrong with you???
For most of the people martial arts are just a small fraction of life. I, of course, have made the mistake of letting it to become pretty much my life, but that doesn't bother me. I see no reason why a martial artist couldn't smoke drugs if he wanted. I don't have to, but I see no reason why not to. As long as you don't do drugs during training and depend them to increase your output, it is fine with me. Also, you shouldn't promote view of drugs to children. For adults, they are perfectly responsible of their own selves. I know that common argument here is that of a restrain and self-discipline. I do not see why a martial artist could not be hedonistic. Why there is a high respect of restrain is because they are taught how to efficently kill and maim other human beings. My body is considered as lethal weapon in the views of Finnish law. Another point is that I do not consider martial arts as sport. Or fighters as athletes.
Just a curiosity, do you think a wushu practicioner should not drink alcohol or is it fine?
Originally Posted by Ne-yo
Like I said you're a fraud. Wushu is not about how to properly throw someone. You have no respect whatsoever for the arts of Wushu.
I will not say that either of you is a fraud via internet. You both might have completely good training it is own way ( refer to my point about internet and martial arts from before). Vastly different viewpoints and my view is more that of ninja has. A realistic, working art comes always first, the possible spirtual aspects after that. You can never achieve inner tranquility if you cannot trust your own ability to protect yourself and others around you.The skill in martial arts is to survive in a conflict, inner or physical. Prevail over anything that would destroy one. Pretty words, but often it is about destroying your attackers will to continue his assault.
Originally Posted by Ne-yo
If you're sincere about the true elements of Wushu then it should have a lot to do with you. It's a union of body and spirit and focusing your ki.
Wushu is a term for chinese martial arts. It is not same as martial arts as whole. The concepts you throw in the air are pretty much the old eastern tradition. What I understand with union of body, spirit and ki is simply that you are able to use your body fully in a fight, casting aside your doubt, honing your fighter instict ( which means to be willing to hurt your opponent) and trust yourself. For the record, yes I have trained arts that embrace the ki term very closely. ( ie. kyoshojutsu, taijiquan). My experiences of ki come more from medical world that in martial one. I have never seen anyone use any of those so-promoted chi techniques in a real fight.
Only techniques the eastern world explains with chi that works for me in fighting are nerve strikes. But they are explained with western medicine as well and I find it easier to understand it with muscles, nerves and joints than with points of fire and water and such. It is just the matter on viewpoints and ways of explaining. If you can tell me any other chi based concept in martial arts I would like to discuss it. The concept of dim mak I won't even discuss.
In short, chi for me is just a concept the eastern world developed in the ancient times to explain things, because they were very advanced in their medical arts, but didn't have the equipment and methods of a modern scientific world to see the real functions within the body. So that you know I also know pretty much about it like in breathing ki, directing ki, rooting yourself with ki, healing with ki, balance of ki
etc.
Originally Posted by ninja9578
And stop talking about ki, only chinese martial arts have any concept of it.
Refer my point on this : http://www.dreamviews.com/f80/martia...51/index3.html
Also ninja, while showing your trophies over internet or your black belt might sound a good idea, it essentially proves nothing.
Pretty much the rest in this post is about Ne-Yo and Ninja grasping each others throats with variety of methods, I won't take part of that. That is personal between you. These points I presented I will gladly discuss in depth.
|
|
Bookmarks