Thread: "Proving" lucid dreams

Originally Posted by freefire

it makes me mad when people dont believe the facts. There right in front of them! I tried telling people i knew about lucid dreaming once. Haha they gave me some funny looks. And my mom thought i was like going over to satan or something I guess its all in how you make it sound. Try explaining a WILD. If you go up and say i know how to wake initiate a lucid dream!!! then people will think you are a nutcase. If you simplify it and just say that you know how to fall asleep consciously then you wont be as frowned upon.

Why does it make you mad? Because for them it isn't that important as it is for you?

Originally Posted by Adam

This has nothing to do with people making themselves feel special. I have been lucid dreaming since a child, and still I tell people about them. Because of the vast amount of uses for lucid dreaming - I feel sharing this is a great thing to do, for the right people. Those truly interested in it, why not share it? If you think something is good, would you hold it back from someone because you think "It's not that special!"

And for these vivid ones (not sure what you mean here, they are all vivid usually) do you not think it is worth sharing with people; for them to experience the same?

Sharing it with people that are interested in it is surely a good thing for both parties. I hadn't met anyone with whom I'd share my lucid experiences and I don't feel bad for it. For me it's not important to share it and i respect those who feel otherwise. Ok, but proving is another matter. Why anyone experienced in LDing would want everyone to believe him? I don't see any point in that.

ld are not real.. thats the fact. prove me wrong.. meh.. you cant..because i had those unreal ld...

So you mean he should only share with those willing to know about it, rather than waste time on those who are too ignorant to listen?

And what is with all the bullshit posts on this forum lately? Is it really worth anyones time posting: "Yeah ld are not real man, cuz I said" - Jeeze if you don't have anything serious to say stay out of the post FFS!

Even Sigmund Freud thought that people who have lucid dreams were just delusional. People don't understand things that they have not experienced. Now that we have scientific proof, you would think that people wouldn't be so ignorant, but sometimes they are.

Originally Posted by Adam

And for these vivid ones (not sure what you mean here, they are all vivid usually) do you not think it is worth sharing with people; for them to experience the same?

I consider vivid ones as those with clarity equal to reality, or even exceeding it.

Originally Posted by Adam

So you mean he should only share with those willing to know about it, rather than waste time on those who are too ignorant to listen?

Yes.

Originally Posted by Adam

And what is with all the bullshit posts on this forum lately? Is it really worth anyones time posting: "Yeah ld are not real man, cuz I said" - Jeeze if you don't have anything serious to say stay out of the post FFS!

They're wrong and the way and place they say it in is funny.

Originally Posted by goldentheponygirl

Even Sigmund Freud thought that people who have lucid dreams were just delusional. People don't understand things that they have not experienced. Now that we have scientific proof, you would think that people wouldn't be so ignorant, but sometimes they are.

Did he really say that? He must have been a very rational man, and I mean orthodox rational. Lol. I think that people are ignorant about this because of that even if they believed in it it wouldn't be important for them because what they didn't experience they don't miss.

To say S. Freud is wrong..it such a foolish stupidity...that.. i will tell this many times..

To deny S. Freud sentences, you must be like him.
To deny that ld are real, or to say they are real, you must get ld yourself.. ( often )
To tell oobe is fake, or illusion, or only in the mind, one must experience it himself ( often )...

if not..then you are a stupid ignorant man.. or woman.

P.S. the fact is that everyone is right... ( only someone might understand more, or someone might have more experience in some, or other kind of stuff.
P.S.S. i dont even bother to insult anyone.. Im not interested in it.

Originally Posted by roguext22

To say S. Freud is wrong..it such a foolish stupidity...that.. i will tell this many times..

To deny S. Freud sentences, you must be like him.
To deny that ld are real, or to say they are real, you must get ld yourself.. ( often )
To tell oobe is fake, or illusion, or only in the mind, one must experience it himself ( often )...

if not..then you are a stupid ignorant man.. or woman.

P.S. the fact is that everyone is right... ( only someone might understand more, or someone might have more experience in some, or other kind of stuff.
P.S.S. i dont even bother to insult anyone.. Im not interested in it.

Now in English, please.

Originally Posted by roguext22

To say S. Freud is wrong..it such a foolish stupidity

Isaac Newton was partly wrong, Galileo Galilei was partly wrong (not in that that the Earth is circulating the Sun), and many other great men were partly wrong... We are only people, after all.

Originally Posted by CloudOne

Isaac Newton was partly wrong, Galileo Galilei was partly wrong (not in that that the Earth is circulating the Sun), and many other great men were partly wrong... We are only people, after all.

I wrote P.S. !!!!

P.S. the fact is that everyone is right... ( only someone might understand more, or someone might have more experience in some, or other kind of stuff.


They were right.. very right!.. but nowadays scientiscs understands more..
I wasnt contradicting myself at all..

Yea I hate it when you try and tell a friend, but then they will just say " Oh yea I have them all the time" hah. thats when I whip out my gatt, and drop a mofo

Wow, thanks for all the replies! I think I'll just shut up about LDs because I'm not coing to convince this guy anyway... yet.. You're right in saying that you have to experience something first hand to judge it. I for instance beleive OBEs are just odd lucid dreams, and I have experienced quite a few so it's a rational judgement. On the other hand when I told my mother about hypnogogic voices if that's what they are, she thought I was schitzophrenic . And she actually has a psycology degree! Is it true lucid dreams are discussed in psycology at all, because I'm doing it next year but my mother never heard of it.

Originally Posted by Idolfan

Is it true lucid dreams are discussed in psycology at all, because I'm doing it next year but my mother never heard of it.

I had psychology this semester and even though we've had one of the best professionals in the country he didn't mention lucid dreams.

About the OBE's I've experienced something similar to it, but only just LD. Probably every OBE is LD in some way.

Originally Posted by Idolfan

Once upon a time lived one of my retarded friends at school. And guess what? He told me that lucid dreams are not real and are a load of bullcrap. I told him to just LOOK at this website and see for himself and he "doesn't want to waste his time".

AAAAAAH! I'm so pissed off! And he's not your average friend either! I won't name names although I'd like to, but he's got his head so far up his own arse it's no wonder he can't see straight! He is the kind of person who'd boast about LDing if he could so I think he's actually telling the truth, he really doesn't think they exist. How can I "prove" to him that they're chuffing real, bearing in mind that in his world the thousands of people on this site are all bots who are put in place to feed the "Great Lucid Scam"!

Tell him to look on Wikipedia.
That'll shut his ass up considering it says in there and I quote "Lucid dreaming has been researched scientifically, and its existence is well established."

Originally Posted by Chaos Theory

Tell him to look on Wikipedia.
That'll shut his ass up considering it says in there and I quote "Lucid dreaming has been researched scientifically, and its existence is well established."

Not to sound pesimistic but everyone can write articles on Wikipedia.

Originally Posted by CloudOne

Not to sound pesimistic but everyone can write articles on Wikipedia.

True, but I heard that the moderators or whatever there change the information immediately if it was false.

Yup. Apparently they don't check user pages much, especially.

When my parents found and read my dream journal without my knowledge, I got in serious trouble because they thought lucid dreaming was something "evil". Not to mention my entries about my sexual dreams that they read too... But I no longer keep a dream journal.

Originally Posted by nullbyte00

When my parents found and read my dream journal without my knowledge, I got in serious trouble because they thought lucid dreaming was something "evil". Not to mention my entries about my sexual dreams that they read too... But I no longer keep a dream journal.

That just sucks. How about keeping an online one if possible?