Penguins in Antarctica are illiterate and don't have views on the afterlife or access to the internet. |
|
Penguins in Antarctica are illiterate and don't have views on the afterlife or access to the internet. |
|
Last edited by really; 07-20-2010 at 09:32 AM.
The Ultimate Lucid Mp3 Thread Link
Mp3 track available here (02/2015): http://www27.zippyshare.com/v/36261038/file.html
If you could conclusively prove that there is a god and an afterlife, I will change my mind. That simple. |
|
This is kind of a wrench in the discussion, but if the universe is expanding and contracting: and will do so forever along the same lines each time, and everything that has ever happened is doomed to be repeated because of this, would that be an after life? Or would it be a different you- so not really you? |
|
Paul is Dead
Well, the contraction bit is open for debate. If the recently-discovered dark matter turns out to be just that, then the universe is likely to reverse its expansion at some point in time. But I digress. If the universe is indeed bound to crunch and explode indefinitely, then all the matter that fell exactly where it is in this universe at this point in time is going to again at some point, given an infinite amount of time. Which means that "you" will exist again some day. But, "you" won't really be existing. You'll have lost all your experiences, memories, consciousness...the "you" has ceased to exist. Rather, you have created an exact matter replica. If you take out the factor of time, assume you could create a person exactly like you down to the atomic level, then go and stand right beside them. You may think exactly the same thoughts and have exactly the same memories, but you are two separate entities, no matter how similar. |
|
Nonsense-talk aside though, you're not accepting that consciousness is independent of whether you're hallucinating or not. The penguin knows of existence, whether it is a "matrix-style" dream or not. Do you see why the hallucination is irrelevant? It is not being relied upon. Consciousness cannot be flawed; it is part of all reality. Concepts and interpretations therein can be flawed. Dreams can be false. But everything in itself is its own truth. Two different realms of experience. The paradox here is that consciousness and existence don't need to be justified or proven. |
|
The Ultimate Lucid Mp3 Thread Link
Mp3 track available here (02/2015): http://www27.zippyshare.com/v/36261038/file.html
But the afterlife does. I know consciousness exists. This I'm not debating. But the afterlife is an entirely different matter. |
|
I have implied that consciousness is an essential quality of life itself, not mere "alertness" or the fact of being conscious (vs. unconscious). Awareness arises out of the intangible nature of life; not a material form. In this sense, investigating consciousness as intrinsic to the nature of life brings about a better understanding of the after-life, even if it is intuited. After all, wouldn't studying more of "life" inside ones awareness help one understand the possibility of the "after-life"? |
|
Last edited by really; 07-22-2010 at 08:52 AM.
The Ultimate Lucid Mp3 Thread Link
Mp3 track available here (02/2015): http://www27.zippyshare.com/v/36261038/file.html
See, I argue that consciousness is not an essential quality of life. Amoebas certainly don't appear sentient. And life itself is rather interesting. To date, we have not discovered any sort of "intangible" nature of life. It is...chemical reactions. Not sure what you're really trying to say here. I'm all for studying life and consciousness and whatnot, but how exactly you are getting the afterlife out of all this is a bit beyond me. |
|
I'm largely convinced that, in the nano seconds before your death, you will experience what seems to you like an eternity, in whatever after-life you so choose to believe in. |
|
You don't get it, you will never discover it because you can't discover "intangible" nature! What is discoverable is tangible. What is intangible has no form. What exactly do you expect? |
|
The Ultimate Lucid Mp3 Thread Link
Mp3 track available here (02/2015): http://www27.zippyshare.com/v/36261038/file.html
That the intangible is an unnecessary thing. If it is truly intangible, it has no impact, no bearing, no observable effect on reality. It is an unnecessary variable in the equation. It is not only nonexistent, but completely unneeded. |
|
If it is truly intangible, you can't detect it because there is no tangibility and no form; that's the definition of intangible. What is intangible is not merely "non-existent", it is only non-existent as tangibility. Awareness is intangible, as are other dimensions. |
|
The Ultimate Lucid Mp3 Thread Link
Mp3 track available here (02/2015): http://www27.zippyshare.com/v/36261038/file.html
Awareness is observable. I can observe it. It has an obvious impact on my reality. This "intangible" nature of yours, conversely, is not observable, has no impact on reality, and is a completely unnecessary variable. It's adding more complexity to the equation that doesn't need to be there. |
|
I think it'd be like before you were |
|
We all live in a kind of continuous dream. When we wake, it is because something,
some event, some pinprick even, disturbs the edges of what we have taken as reality.
Vandermeer
SAT (Sporadic Awareness Technique) Guide
Have questions about lucid dreaming? DM me.
Do you know what it was like before you were born, according to your current knowledge? |
|
The Ultimate Lucid Mp3 Thread Link
Mp3 track available here (02/2015): http://www27.zippyshare.com/v/36261038/file.html
That is exactly the point: you didn't exist. You have no memory of that time, and had no consciousness. A return to that state would not only be the most logical, but the simplest. Even if you did somehow live on, without knowing that you exist or having any memory at all, it doesn't really matter. |
|
We all live in a kind of continuous dream. When we wake, it is because something,
some event, some pinprick even, disturbs the edges of what we have taken as reality.
Vandermeer
SAT (Sporadic Awareness Technique) Guide
Have questions about lucid dreaming? DM me.
If I couldn't remember, it is best not to draw an immediate conclusion, and so simply find some other method. Memory is unreliable. It is easy to say that people forget things, but that's not to say certain things never happened at all. |
|
The Ultimate Lucid Mp3 Thread Link
Mp3 track available here (02/2015): http://www27.zippyshare.com/v/36261038/file.html
Regardless, if you can't remember your life, "you" cease to exist. |
|
It is really disappointing how shallow you're making this. I may as well forget the discussion therefore making it "cease" to exist. And you don't see the flaw in the simple wording? |
|
The Ultimate Lucid Mp3 Thread Link
Mp3 track available here (02/2015): http://www27.zippyshare.com/v/36261038/file.html
If everyone forgets it in entirety and all record that it ever happened is removed, it effectively does cease to exist. It perhaps existed in the past, but the conscious embodiment of this argument certainly doesn't linger. I see no flaws. If you lose all your memories and start over at square one, "you" as you are right now is no more. He has ceased to exist. He has been replaced, and in doing so, has been eliminated. It doesn't matter if some conscious entity continues on if it doesn't remember a goddamn thing. |
|
Mario and Really, you two are arguing about the difference between realism and idealism. realism saying that the only things that exist exist because of some fundamental physical laws, and all perception is based on that. Idealism stating the opposite, that the idea of reality as being physically external isn't true, and that all is made up from the mind , and consciousness comes from the mind/unknown, as opposed to the mind coming from physical existence, and consciousness therefore being a perception of physical existence of the external. |
|
LD goals: Talk to a DC [X] Share a dream [X] Find my Dream guide [] Have an LD without a dream body, only images [] Dream share with my dad [X] Fight a one vs one against a self aware DC [] Free fall/stop an inch before the ground [X] Be fearless [X] Walk into a mirror [X] Use a portal to teleport [] Recall all dreams/3 dreams a night+ [] Master the four elements [] Fight with a "firebender" [] Easy and advanced TOTM in one LD [] Stop a vehicle/train with my bare hands []
My dj: Adventures and experiments
LD count since joining: 32
MILD: 15 DILD: 10 WILD: 0 DEILD: 7
Man, your onto it! I'm surprised no one has mentioned DMT yet.. DMT is the most POWERFUL hallucogenic in the world. Far more powerful than LSD and even Salvia. It is realised at the moment you are born, which is interesting enough. It is realised when you sleep, to prevent a build up which would kill you. And I bet you all know what that causes. Without DMT, none of us would be on this forum now discussing the afterlife-DMT causes dreams. And, what I find the MOST interesting, is what happens at the moment you die. All of the DMT that has being building up since the moment you began, is FLOODED into the brain and you will trip your fucking balls off! There is 5-6 minutes of brain activity after you die, in which time will have NO meaning from your perception, people who have the synthesized version say thre trip seemed to last for hours, even though just 5 minutes minutes will have past since they started there enlightening trip. Yes, this all very proven, and I do think that in some senses, we will be able to control the trip. BUT, how good we are in this life, sorry, how HAPPY we are in this life, I think will directly affect how enjoyable the trip is. Drugs and lucid dreaming will help. There is NO such thing as 'AFTER LIFE'. After life, comes death, rendering you as concious as a pencil. Whether there is life after your body dies however, is another matter. |
|
Don Piper's story sounds very fascinting indeed. Sounds like I want to read that book. |
|
Luminous Spacious Dream Masters That Holographically Communicate
among other teachers taught me
not to overestimate the Value of our Concrete Knowledge;"Common sense"/Rationality,
for doing so would make us Blind for the unimaginable, unparalleled Capacity of and Wisdom contained within our Felt Knowledge;Subconscious Intuition.
Bookmarks