Thread: lucid dreams?

Originally Posted by Robot_Butler

The main definition of a lucid dream is that you know you are dreaming. Normally when people talk about lucid dreams, they mean a dream in which you actually do something with the knowledge that you are dreaming. I would say #2 is the best definition of what a lucid dream really is.

Some rare people seem to always be able to recognize the feeling of dreaming. We have a few members who are naturals, like this.

Have you ever had a lucid where you were having a bunch of fun and decided to go with the flow of events? Also I've had plenty of times (when I started out) where I realized I was dreaming, but I just couldn't get anything to work. I was still lucid, but I was lacking control. In my opinion, #2 is the optimal choice, but not the best definition; 1 and 2 are still lucid dreams.

The actual definition is, knowing that you're dreaming while you are dreaming.

Of course control and etc. is fun, but that's not the definition. The definition is simply knowing that you're dreaming. Lucidity =/= dream control.

Shift, I think to people who actually make it a priority to LD...... control and stuff in a broader sense is The Definition.

It's not the 'definition', it's the motivation. There already is a definition to lucid dreaming- knowing that you are dreaming while you are dreaming. (Dream control is conspicuously absent)

Originally Posted by Shift

It's not the 'definition', it's the motivation. There already is a definition to lucid dreaming- knowing that you are dreaming while you are dreaming. (Dream control is conspicuously absent)

Different for everyone I guess, but knowing you're dreaming, and the former+ interaction by your own WILL is different for me with the latter as my definition

Originally Posted by Squaddle

Different for everyone I guess, but knowing you're dreaming, and the former+ interaction by your own WILL is different for me with the latter as my definition

No, A Lucid dream is simply knowing you are dreaming. This is true for everyone, regardless of whether or not you accept it. Once one realizes they are dreaming, they could choose to sit down in a corner and stare at wall until the dream ends, and it would still be a Lucid Dream.

It is also possible to have control over a dream without being Lucid at all.

For me control isn't even the motivation, it's the sweet freedom that can't be had anywhere else.

Originally Posted by Caradon

No, A Lucid dream is simply knowing you are dreaming. This is true for everyone, regardless of whether or not you accept it. Once one realizes they are dreaming, they could choose to sit down in a corner and stare at wall until the dream ends, and it would still be a Lucid Dream.

It is also possible to have control over a dream without being Lucid at all.

For me control isn't even the motivation, it's the sweet freedom that can't be had anywhere else.

When I say WILL it, I didn't mean dream control, I mean realizing you are dreaming and in turn can do what you want to, as you have stated, sit there till the dream ends.

I think you're confusing the actual definition of a term with what you consider a worthwhile pursuit.

Caradon said it.