 Originally Posted by Thor
Unless we want to hopelessly confuse the discussion, let's first distinguish between REM atonia and sleep paralysis, the former being natural and the latter being a sleep disorder.
If you are in sleep paralysis, you cannot possibly know that you have it before you have tried to move and failed. If you don't report the symptom, you don't have the disorder. It would be analogous to saying "I had a horrible headache; I didn't feel any pain at all, but I just know I had it."
Ah, I beg to differ Thor.
I have the disorder Sleep Paralysis and have experienced SP an unimaginable amount of times. By unimaginable, try to think of experiencing SP at least 3 times a month (more or less) or once every other a week (again more or less) (these numbers are estimates of course, but Id say very close to the actual number) for sevens years . My first experience with SP was when I was 11; how did I know I was in SP? Simply put, I was conscious and couldn't move, that's how. Of course I didn't know about REM Atonia or SP until I was about 14. But the point is, once you've experienced SP as many times as I have, you get to the point where you don't necessarily "have" to move to know that you're in it at all. After experiencing SP on an "every-other-weekly" basis, you began to notice a pattern or a certain "feeling", if you will, of SP/REM Atonia. So to say that one has to try to move in order to know that they are in SP is incorrect. Please do not tell me that I'm incorrect because this is not coming from a scientific source, its coming from introspection.
 Originally Posted by Thor
I've seen many people here on DV say things like: "be careful not to move, or you'll break SP." What kind of paralysis "breaks" when you try to move? None; it's a contradiction.
Again, more introspection.
The thing I found about SP is that when you "try" to move, most often in a state of panic, you're sending a message to your brain that you're not unconscious (or your mind isn't asleep), and hence, not supposed to be in SP, which in turn, releases the paralysis. Every time I experienced SP (besides the times that I WILD with a WBTB), I woke myself by relentlessly trying to move until I did, in fact, wake up, moments after falling back to asleep. So its not a contradiction, its the way the body works. SP is, after all, a disorder, so a paralysis is sure to be lifted once the brain becomes aware that something is out of order.
|
|
Bookmarks