^^ That.
 Originally Posted by MemeViews
I use the plugged nose RC. And you say RC's won't get you lucid... but if I were to do a plugged nose RC out of habit in my dream then I would instantly get lucid! It just has to turn into a habit first.
Sadly, and contrary to the popular internet mythology, it does not work that way. State tests (RC's) are not meant make to make you lucid; they are meant to confirm that you are dreaming, or not.
RC's are meant to do two things:
First (and foremost), RC's confirm that you are not dreaming: They are state tests that you do when you have a feeling you might be dreaming, or perhaps have seen a dreamsign that indicates you could be in a dream. These confirmations are done primarily during waking-life, are done after you sincerely ask yourself the question, "Is this a dream?" and are always done after you have decided to question your state; not before. Keep in mind that LaBerge called them Reality Checks, and not Dream checks; the difference is significant.
The second role of RC's is to help you to initiate a moment during waking-life when you can do things like imagine everything around you being a dream, or perhaps pay attention to your presence in the moment (aka, thinking lucidly). Those moments are very helpful, when taken often and sincerely, toward building a lucid mindset that may follow you into your dream and cause you to wonder, during the dream, if you are dreaming -- and then do a RC to confirm it!
What RC's do not do is make you lucid on their own; that is not their purpose. If you make a habit of doing RC's during the day, and do them often, sure, you will likely do RC's during dreams thanks to day residue, and one of two things will likely happen: You will either (non-lucidly) do your RC and it will fail, confirming to your DC You that you are awake; or -- thanks to your dreaming mind obligingly fulfilling your expectation -- your RC will "work" (i.e., you'll still be breathing with your nose plugged), and you will then have a NLD about being lucid, perhaps filled with lots of stuff you hope to do when lucid, but all without the real presence of your waking-life Self.
I think the rise of the mythology that RC's make you lucid is based on the possibility that dreamers forget that they were already lucid when they decided to do a RC in a dream. This sort of makes sense, because the suspicion that "this might be a dream," is far less powerful than the "Ah-Ha!" moment that follows a successful RC, and so the Ah-Ha moment shoves the original suspicion from memory.
A couple of less important notes: First, habits are not always good things. If doing RC's becomes a habit for you, then you risk allowing them to be a function that you do by rote (like brushing your teeth), and you will give them very little thought as you're doing them. I think it is much better to have each RC be important to you as you do it, and to avoid letting them become a habit. Also, if anecdotally, I have had thousands of DILDs over the years, and I'm pretty sure I have never become lucid by doing a RC. Try to keep your RC's sincere and fresh, and they will be a much better tool for you than simply doing them habitually.
I guess the bottom line here is that you really must already suspect you are dreaming in order for a RC to work during a dream; and by work I mean it is confirming that you are dreaming, and lucid; it is not making you lucid on its own. This, when combined with their role in daywork, still makes RC's a powerful tool for lucidity, but in a different way than seems to be their popularly, if incorrectly, accepted role these days.
tl;dr: RC's don't make you lucid; they confirm your lucidity. You must already suspect you are dreaming in order for a RC to work. If you do RC's with the expectation that they alone will make you lucid, then you will probably not become lucid.
|
|
Bookmarks