Originally Posted by Abra
Regarding placebo...
Even the binaural websites say that you must focus on the beats, and meditate along with them, to work. Can they not work on their own for some reason? And how can you tell the difference between effects from meditation, and effects from binaurals?
I'm just saying, don't waste your money on these. As there are free versions abound, and I'm certain there's no difference from the pay sites.
Yes, one gets the most out of them when one meditate, given that one is using the correct frequencies for that purpose. Though binaural beats can also be effective in other situations, against pain; during/post surgery and for enhanced learning in some circumstances.
Since this is a lucid dreaming forum the purpose of using binaural beats should mainly be meditation. The question of whether it work on its own or not is a tricky one. I would say yes, but only to the degree that one don't counter-act the effect, if one is relaxed and comfortable it can do something. It will only help if it is allowed to do so.
The problem is defining "meditation". If one relaxes and calm the mind, it is or can be meditation, what binaural beats does is that it speeds up the process and/or makes it easier to achieve a desired state of consciousness. It might be a semantic problem regarding that question.
It does not require much experimentation to see the possible effect of binaural beats vs. unaided. One can use simply statistical methods, over time one gets a picture.
One important thing is to see binaural beats as helpful thing, but only to certain limits. It's best for the introduction, one should rather be able to achieve desired states unaided, but if that requires some help at first then binaural beats can be excellent for that. See it as training wheels on a bicycle, when one learns to bike properly the training wheels will only be a hindrance to one, one must realize this and let go of it. This can be said of almost all techniques or "rituals" for anything, but it's very relevant for such thing as meditation.
I wouldn't pay for it too, there are many free ones and one can easily make them for oneself.
Let me state that binaural beats are not a necessary thing, but can be quite helpful for many people. I just advice simple personal experimentation, it might just do wonders.
|
|
Bookmarks