I was referring specifically to this...
 Originally Posted by EthicalEye
their 5 mins of rehearsals in Dream World is better or equal to 1 hour in Waking Life.
which is not true. 5 minutes will not equal 1 hour. Inception is pure fiction.
An artist drawing creative inspiration from dreams and lucid dreams is not the same as practicing a skill in a dream. Dali manipulated his dreams to give him ideas of what to paint. He didn't practice painting in dreams.
 Originally Posted by EthicalEye
Being a virtual reality simulation, the lucid dream world is an ideal place to practice real life skills - from the perfect flying kick to playing classical piano.
It's not ideal. You learn a flying kick in real life by understanding exactly what your muscles are capable of doing while bound by the the laws of physics. There are no physics in dreams. Sure you can recreate them, but there's no way to know whether or not they are truly accurate. If your simulated dream physics aren't perfectly accurate then what you learn won't be accurate either.
Playing piano is a little different. The piano is just the tool used to create musical notes. The musical notes themselves are intuitive. Anyone that has spent time listening to music knows what is musical and what isn't. In a dream you can eliminate the piano and just play the notes with your mind. You don't rely on physics in any way. Just your knowledge of the different notes and octaves on the piano.
 Originally Posted by EthicalEye
Likewise, in the book Exploring The World of Lucid Dreaming by Dr Stephen LaBerge and Howard Rheingold, a surgeon explains how, before going to sleep at night, he would review his surgical cases for the next day. Then he would become lucid in his dreams and practice them in precise detail. As a result, he was able to refine and polish his techniques and perform procedures much faster than the average surgeon. He credited his edge to lucid dreaming.
It's been a while since I read that book, but here's my take on the surgeons explanation. Surgery involves many small tasks that must be performed in the correct order. The surgeon in his dream was not practicing the finesse required to perform the tasks but the order in which they must be done. Just because he credited his edge to lucid dreaming doesn't mean it actually gave him one.
Using lucid dreams to practice physical skills is still just a theory, and I believe that is how it was presented in the LaBerge book. Not proven. Just an interesting idea. If your lucid dream is an exact model of reality then yes, I think you could do physical practice that translates to reality. But realistically how often do you have a lucid dream that is not only an exact model of reality but maintains that exactness for a length of time? And if the exactness falters would you even know it?
|
|
Bookmarks