I just deleted my whole post, I wanted to make a coherent one where I don't drift away lol.
Situation:
1.Person X says they found their dream guide.
2.Person Y says they found their dream guide.
3.Person Z meets a dream character who claims to be her dream guide.
Problem:
If person X and Y have totally different concepts of what a DG implies, is one of them wrong?
a) If one of them is wrong, then there's no way you can safely determine the validity of a DG.
b) if none of them is wrong, then that means a DG can imply many things, and there's nothing to support that it is more than a dream character who possesses self-fulfilling prophecy's characteristics.
How can person Z find out if that DC is really her dream guide? She can't. That means that any expectation leading process that results into a DC proclaiming itself as being your DG may be simply that: not a subconscious representation (not more than the dream itself anyway), but self-fulfilling prophecy.
“Are you my subconscious?”
He says, " No " the first two times with slight mumbling then on the third he says " Yes! "
I yell out loud, " Woo-Hoo! "
I mean really? Your subconscious is a specific entity shelved into a DC? People should first explain what they define at subconscious, especially because most of the new age subconscious is a lot of talk under the effects of confirmation and selection bias. This concept of DG, in my opinion, is inside of it. Besides, it will be always a product of subjective nature. This can be verified to some point when you read reports of DG findings. I'm not going ahead of myself to say that the majority of these reports follow this trend, but many of it relate typical story of people finding their DG when they showed in some way to have a pre-conceived idea of what a DG is. This seems pretty relevant to me as well.
Except for the sole article of Rebbeca Turner (which I enjoyed), those links don't seem very reliable. NPL is considered a pseudo-science, and the other article also has some errors and bold claims, like "your subconscious mind knows you better than you know you, and can give you vast amounts of insight and wisdom which can help when soul searching". Don't get me wrong though, I still find the topic interesting and I do agree with some "subconscious" definitions, it's nice you made this topic (I'm hoping the discussion will carry on ^^).
|
|
Bookmarks