Thread: would it be a sin?

Originally Posted by Nefarious

I would not think this is a sin, because in a lucid dream you can control your charcter that you would for example would want to rape. Even if you cant if you are lucid and your a good person who would not want to rape anyone you would try to think that the person you are raping is ok with that. Thus this is not a sin cause you dont really wana cause harm to anyone you just want to use your chance to have fun, you know that youre not hurting anyone and you wont do it in real life.

I think most religious people would still think its a sin. Religious people are quite simple minded, they rely too much on their belifs and would think that if its in your head it may develop to reality too. I dont think they would belive that a person who imagine himself rape someone in a lucid dream would not commit a serious sin in reality.

Wait bro, i think you are judging religious people way too quickly. i mean im not religious but you see religious people think the way they do not because they are afraid of it's outcome but because it is a commandment of their God. Its just people following the rules they have chosen to follow.