 Originally Posted by sivason
I am fine with that. We barely knew each other then, and you have an interesting take on things.
OK, then we're good there. This is my hope, that the song gets through, so to speak, which I guess is your main concern also. I realize I've been on your case a lot lately, and I'm not happy about that.
 Originally Posted by sivason
I did not literally mean they should never try it as an experiment.
OK.
 Originally Posted by sivason
As far as you suggesting it can be induced because it is a part of OBE, I am saying it is either the state I refer to (that is not SP) that is used in OBE, or that anyone who does use SP has a medical condition they are using, and it is not useful for anyone else. The guy who wanted to argue, says he experienced it PRIOR to his study of it, then says anyone can do it. IF he claims to know this because HE can do it,,, well I claim he already had it as a condition, so what does his experience prove?
What I and Shalashaska are saying is we don't think its that clear cut, between medical condition and no medical condition. Like a lot of medical conditions, its a symptom or category of symptoms, without a single, universal cause, and it can be cultivated. I agree with you that not everyone can do it, but then I think that's generally true of lucid dreaming also. I'm predisposed to both, which I guess is a matter of genetics and karma, but I don't think its fair to treat it as a congenital disease. And I think its reasonable for Shalashaska to claim that it can be cultivated based on his experience doing that, even though I would argue against doing that. Anecdotally, based on people I know, many of other people besides him have experienced sleep paralysis but it hasn't recurred for them because they've shied away from it, just as they've shied away from lucid dreaming.
Most people regard lucid dreaming as abnormal, if they even know what it is. If medical industry politics were to go a slightly different way it could very easily be defined as a medical condition. All of my lucid dreaming experiences have been largely involuntary, and I prefer it that way, as a matter of specialization and trust between myself and my other half, so to speak. But I don't think this disqualifies me from knowing that its possible to cultivate it.
Again, I'm not at all endorsing the cultivation of sleep paralysis, personally I wouldn't do that, and I'd advise against it. But as you know I'm not sold on astral projection either.
I apologize for implying that someone deleted a post, though I wasn't thinking it was you. It wasn't a fair accusation in relation DreamViews either, even though I've come to expect this sort of thing from experiences on other sites.
Check out my 'branch off the tulpa thread' from a few days ago in the dream interpretation forum if you are inclined to. It contains a dream from my sister from last week that we've only partially figured out. This is one of those dreams that has well designed synchronicities with other things that are happening, its more than just personal to her own issues, even though there's that side of it too.
Also, Sageous, I see that Athanor has made a couple of posts there recently. He only gives a fairly narrow range of interpretations, but he's clear about the limitations and does it quite well, in my opinion.
[p.s. I'd like to apologize for going a little bit too far with my paranoia, now I wish I hadn't said a couple of things that I said in my post earlier this evening.]
|
|
Bookmarks