 Originally Posted by De-lousedInTheComatorium
Yeah, but there's a difference between two people of the same sex who are both at a certain age, and an old, experienced pedophile with a young inexperienced child. In homosexuality nothing is being taken advantage of, but in pedophilia the pedophile is taking advantage of the immaturity of the child.
You think I have not heard this argument before? It's the same reasons why religious people should not manipulate their children. I know this.
The unfortunate truth is that there are actually some children out there who genuinely want this. What do you do about them? It's not something we want to face or admit, but there are people who want it.
Of course, taking advantage of someones will is always wrong. However, what about the cases in which there is no manipulation?
And there's not anything you can do to take every pedophile off of the map, but I get a smile on my face when I see pedophiles who start crying on Dateline's To Catch a Predator, because they've been caught with their pants down and embarassed on national television.
Now imagine how they feel at your laughter. Some of these people truly know what they are doing is wrong, but they cannot help it. It's like being addicted to a drug that's ruining your life. They want to seek help, but there's so much ridicule that it's even hard to admit that they have this problem without someone making fun of them for it.
My point here is really that ridiculing never helps. Although it may be wrong, we shouldn't assume that they are all intrinsically evil for doing such things.
 Originally Posted by Oneironaut
Oh, don't get me wrong. I wasn't trying to make it look like you actually promoted that sort of thing. I understand exactly what you were trying to say.
My point is that some things are worth fighting against, no matter whether or not you can actually stamp out the problem. We will no more easily get rid of pedophiles than we will get rid of murderers. But would you not prevent a single, cold-blooded murder of an innocent, if it was within your power? Do you just ignore each individual case, simply because of the fact that the overall problem will never go away?
Well, as I said before, there are cases in which the two parties both do not want intervention. What about those?
We can regulate it as much as we want and try to suppress it, but how much time is going to be spent in this? It is going to happen whether you like it or not, no matter how much effort is being put into stopping it.
Perhaps what might help is actually offering a sense of community for those that realize what they are doing is wrong. Some take it too far and some do need coercive help.
I'm really not sure what to say on the matter. I don't think the way in which people treat pedophiles helps though. I have a fetish and it is really mild, yet I get made fun of it a lot whenever mentioned. I can't imagine how someone who knows that they do not like their fetish, wants to get rid of it, but can't even admit it without being ridiculed feels.
Even after therapy is put to place, there's still ridiculing done. Just take a look at "A Clockwork Orange" which does a beautiful job of showing just how unforgiving people can be. (Yes, it is just a movie, but I'd rather source that as a demonstration of people's behaviour than actual behaviour.. unless you want me to).

 Originally Posted by Carôusoul
I'm all for protecting children, my question is how society should treat a completely peaceful nice person [with no intentions of carrying out anything] who happens to be attracted to children.
Well said. My thoughts exactly.
~
|
|
Bookmarks