LawyerFrank:
Let me begin by saying: I'm a supplement noob myself. I've read Yuschak's book (Advanced Lucid dreaming) and another paper of his, and other than that I go by anecdotal experiences on here and on various google results. I've probably had a grand total of 10 supplement nights altogether, I'm traveling now so I have the opportunity to experiment without having to explain what these 10 bottles of weird-sounding stuff is all about, not to mention a 1-pound bag of cut-up wormwood that just arrived, and the 2oz pack of mugwort . So it looks like I do "supplements a lot" but it's just the density of the usage that makes it look like that. So all this is just IMO.
I've also been on a fairly nasty 1-month dreaming and lucid dry spell and I've been looking for ways to nudge myself out of that and build up some positive expectation again. I really understand the motivation to reach for supplements, but I've been in serious everyday LD practice for over 8 months now mostly with no supplements. So there is *something* to trying for longer, and giving it more time for your self-awareness, memory, and dream recall/awareness to build up more and come all together.
However us "mature" guys may just need a boost from time to time.
Really my major recommendations are: 1) experiment, it's the only way to find what works for you, and 2) take it slow, minimum dosage at first, building over time as needed to see results, either until you find a reliable dosage, or determine that it's just not going to work for you at the dosages you're willing to take. Oh, the 0-level recommendation is: read the Yuschak book first.
Another point is: invest in "getting back to sleep" technique without supplements before taking them. These supplements work by stimulating brain activity and that can mean wakefulness. Understand and accept without frustration (since that leads to anxiety and negative expectation) that in the beginning, you may be up for a while, maybe until morning. Cultivate a calm, happy, peaceful attitude, and eventually (if you take them early enough) you will drift to sleep. Everyone says "get up after 5 hours to take supplements" I tried 4 and someone recommended 3.5 even. Most important is to get back to sleep, then try to slowly move the supplement time closer to your peak dreaming hours.
Let me say that I'm not entirely sure exactly what gave me my nice results of the last few days. It *could* have been simply: REM suppression and WBTB. Or maybe just simply long WBTBs. It will take more experimentation to find out for sure.
My GOAL is supplement-free nights full of long awesome vivid dreams, with a heaping helping of lucidity. I'm just now trying to get myself kickstarted again and hopefully not waste all of this solo bed time on this trip due to jet lag recovery.
Now, my first reaction is: if 5-HTP gives you violent, bizarre, memorable dreams, I'd say: SCORE! That's the goal! Those dreams make you sit up and pay attention (in addition to keeping you swept up in emotions, so that's the flipside). Dreams that give me a quick shock are better than those with a slow long wallow in strong emotions, but anything that creates memorable dreams absolutely must be on the list.
I really like the notion of starting just with REM suppression; melatonin and 5-HTP taken at bedtime can result in deep restful sleep in the first part of the night (dosage depending on how long), and REM-biased sleep in the 2nd half. The absolute best results so far have been: 1 night with 3mg melatonin at bed time and that's all, and 1 night with body builder muscle protein/vitamin/carb blend at bedtime. The former made me wake up feeling like crap about to swear off all supplements forever, but after a long BTB I had long vivid dreams where I realized I had been dreaming for a long time, got lucid twice. The protein powder resulted in late morning long vivid bizarre action-packed dreams with brief lucidity at the end.
It's really hard to say without long studies what really happened. Maybe my dreaming just finally caught up with my continuing awareness work?
I"m jealous about the African Dream Root, the notion that taking it in the morning ever day for 3 months can *permanently* give you awesome vivid dreams all night long is well, awesome. Also smacks a bit of "too good to be true". Maybe there are other things that change permanently? Anyway, if you're going to do that, you should probably avoid all other supplements. I have no idea about stacking/interactions with ADR and anything else.
My Galantamine night was the Yuschak recommendation, "multiple trigger" 5-HTP at bedtime for REM suppression and deep restful sleep in the 1st half of the night, then galantamine + choline(s). choline bitartrate hits fast, alpha-gpc hits later, that's the reason to take both so the effective period of the galantamine lasts longer. Read Yuschak, again, and don't try galantamine more than once every 4 nights unless you're going to take the "pirecetam(?)" to avoid desensitization.
So that's a jumble of stuff if anything's unclear let me know!
p.s. just to clarify what "experiment" means: try various: 1) dosages, 2) kinds of supplements and combinations, 3) timings (at bedtime? at 5 hrs? 4 hrs? etc.). One other thing Yuschak recommends is to mix things up: so your body "never knows what's coming" and can't get used to it. And take breaks once in a while to let everything flush out.
|
|
Bookmarks