I agree with most of your post. Yes, Aristaeus had productive criticism, hence why I was able to rewrite it by just changing a few words, and I even agree with a couple of his points. And yes, criticism is something every serious author must go through, it's what helps them improve. But did MeannCat say at any time that she was a professional author? I've reread the whole thing a couple times, and I don't see that statement anywhere.
 Originally Posted by MeannCat
Thanks for your suggestions, but in truth this was simply written out of boredom.
It sounds to me like it's just a hobby that she felt like sharing, just because she found joy in writing it and wanted others to experience the same joy from reading it. If I had paid $20 for JK Rowling's new Harry Potter book, and the whole thing was written with shallow characters, poor plot development, and typographical errors, yeah I'd be pissed too. And I'd have a right to be pissed, she's a professional, she gets paid a ton for what she does, so anything less than her best is a ripoff (plus she would've cost me 20 bucks). But when MeannCat's sharing something she enjoys doing, not for a job but because she just likes it, it becomes less about you giving helpful criticism an more about you tearing her down, saying she is terrible at having fun.
For example, one of my hobbies is playing video games. I suck at a lot of them, but I have fun playing, so I do it anyway. Say I upload a YouTube video of me sucking at Super Mario World, but I'm having fun doing it. The reason I'm sharing the video is not to show off how good of a player I am (because I know I'm nowhere near professional), but to hopefully share some of the joy that I get from playing the game to others - not trying to earn praise, but trying to give others joy. Then suppose a random YouTube commenter comes along and tears me down, claiming that I'm a horrible video game player, that I should be disappointed at how I can't even finish the first level without dying 5 times in a pit, and that I'll never beat the world record speedrun for completing Bowser's Castle since I can't even execute the weird little spin jump mechanic that for some reason never shows up in another 2D Mario platformer ever again. He's not criticizing my skill anymore, he's basically trying to make me feel ashamed for finding joy in such a pathetic venture. If I did try to follow their "advice", I would be ultimately changing my whole reason for doing what I do, and ultimately find less joy in it, since now I'm just doing it to seek approval from the haters. So yes, I'm concerned that harsh words might discourage her from writing, because it seems like writing is something she enjoys doing, and criticism for criticism's sake really just diminishes that joy.
Now if someone had given me that level of criticism on my programming skills (which is actually what I want to do with my life), I would take heed, because when I'm on the job, I'm going to be designing products for others, and should strive to make it the best that it can be for other people's sake. But this really doesn't seem like the case here.
Unfortunately, those kind of comments happen on YouTube all the time (that's another rant for another time), but I like to think that it's different here at DreamViews. We have a diverse audience of all different countries, ages, ethnicities, and religions. We each have different skills and creativities, we each have our own things we deal with each day, but we don't judge each other. Instead we look for ways to help each other, both in dreaming and in real life. I'm not saying that you need to praise everything everyone does, like the overzealous soccer mom that thinks everything their son or daughter does is the best. But you don't have to tear down someone else's pleasures just to prove a point.
|
|
Bookmarks