What's the difference between OBE and lucid dreams? |
|
I've been trying this for four nights now without success.(The indirect method) I am constantly scrutinising my efforts and improving my approach. There are some very innovative ideas in the book, but Mr Radiga could do well to explain some of the ideas in more depth. Forced back to sleep, for example. The explanation of that is rushed and leaves one in doubt as to what it is, and how to do it. |
|
What's the difference between OBE and lucid dreams? |
|
I believe that OBEs are just a specific type of lucid dream, thought some believe they are a different state. |
|
I have a little trouble reading the book, his word of choice are too sophisticated for me to comprehend most of it, but I sort of get the idea. When you attempt the indirect technique, is it like a WBTB or is it anytime when you awoken from a sleep? |
|
Ideally you do it after WBTB, but after a while when you have a experience you can switch to using it every awakening. With phantom wiggling you're supposed to try to move any body part without using muscles. You are supposed to start slowly and amplify the movement and then use the movement of that dream body to leave your real body. |
|
Yes, I think that it is, but as I haven't had success yet I probably can't offer much guidance. Mcwillis has had success with the technique and started this thread so maybe you should ask him. |
|
I've been trying this technique for seven days now and I'm nowhere near achieving lucidity with it. The two problems I'm having are: |
|
Last edited by Bobblehat; 08-13-2011 at 04:53 PM. Reason: Forgot something
a few days ago I managed to hit the vibrational state and rolled myself |
|
Join our Lucid Dreaming video game project!
Lucid Dreams: 6 ---- WILD: 0
---------------------- MILD: 2
---------------------- EILD: 0
---------------------- DILD: 4
---------------------- DEILD: 0
I had four LDs last night. I think these techniques were a factor in two of them (both FAs). The other two were DILDs. Will continue to experiment and report back with successes. |
|
My question is, are the WILD's produced through this method exactly the same as a traditional WILD? By that I mean is the realism and stability as powerful as it is normally? |
|
Do you HAVE to wake up naturally for this?!?! |
|
DILD's: 54 | WILD's: 1 | DEILD's: 6
Max LD's in one night: 4
"Life is 10% what happens to me 90% how I react to it." - John C. Maxwell
"We are often find uncertainty more unpleasant
than unpleasant certainty - at least if we look, we know."
"Failing to act, for fear of the risk,
is no different than a living death."
Hey! I am going to try this along with my timer method, because the indirect techniques seems to be alot like a movement free reality check. |
|
no but it will help and be far more likely on the occasions when you wake up naturally straight after a dream because you will still be close to rem mode. an alarm can shock you out of that, but a gentle alarm can be used to wake you slowly, as long as you dont have to move alot to turn it off. |
|
Read a few pages so far. This looks like a fantastic resource and I look forward to delving further into it. Thanks for posting, McWillis |
|
My Lucid Dreaming Articles/Tutorials:
Mindfulness - An Alternative Approach to ADA
Intent in Lucid Dreaming; Break that Dry-Spell, Escape the Technique Rut
Always, no sometimes think it's me,
But you know I know when it's a dream
I think I know I mean a yes
But it's all wrong
That is I think I disagree
-John Lennon
There is also a YouTube video that helps to give a nice overview of the techniques. |
|
When it talks about 'training' indirect methods, should training be done at any time or upon awakening without moving/opening eyes? |
|
My Lucid Dreaming Articles/Tutorials:
Mindfulness - An Alternative Approach to ADA
Intent in Lucid Dreaming; Break that Dry-Spell, Escape the Technique Rut
Always, no sometimes think it's me,
But you know I know when it's a dream
I think I know I mean a yes
But it's all wrong
That is I think I disagree
-John Lennon
As in the video he says indirect methods require initial sleep, he suggests the average WBTB of 5 hours, essentially once you perform WBTB with an alarm clock you stay awake for 5 minutes you then use autosuggestion to wake up in the next 2-3 hours, so without an alarm this time go back to sleep and attempt to wake up in 2-3 hours. Also when you're telling yourself don't use repetition its important to have confidence, affirm yourself but don't for instance make a mantra such as "I will wake up in 2 hours and remain still" you could but that would kind of defeat the purpose of this technique because you might not fall asleep. |
|
Last edited by Drax; 08-22-2011 at 12:21 AM.
Thanks for the info, Draxquin |
|
Last edited by Ctharlhie; 08-22-2011 at 10:48 AM.
My Lucid Dreaming Articles/Tutorials:
Mindfulness - An Alternative Approach to ADA
Intent in Lucid Dreaming; Break that Dry-Spell, Escape the Technique Rut
Always, no sometimes think it's me,
But you know I know when it's a dream
I think I know I mean a yes
But it's all wrong
That is I think I disagree
-John Lennon
A few days after reading the indirect techniques, I had a chain of 4 DEILD's.. It was pretty awesome. |
|
DILD's: 54 | WILD's: 1 | DEILD's: 6
Max LD's in one night: 4
"Life is 10% what happens to me 90% how I react to it." - John C. Maxwell
"We are often find uncertainty more unpleasant
than unpleasant certainty - at least if we look, we know."
"Failing to act, for fear of the risk,
is no different than a living death."
Would be interested to see some independent statistics on how effective these techniques are, both in the short term and the long term. After 16 days of concentration on these techniques I've yet to experience a lucid dream I could confirm as being a result of the application of the techniques. Starting to get sceptical, if I'm honest. I'm off work so have been able to concentrate on memorising the techniques so that I can perform them habitually on waking. Have followed Mr Raduga's instructions in his guidebook verbatim. But nothing. Will remain open minded for now and will take a break for a few days. Will then return to trying the techniques then, if no results after a few days, will switch to MILD again and relying on the soul destroying lucky dip that is DILD. Would be interested in setting up an experiment to get people to try the techniques and produce our own stats as to how effective they are. |
|
That's fab, but I'm not sure that the Raduga techniques should get any credit for that. DEILDing - or dream chaining - has been around for quite a long time, and rolling out of the body is discussed in ETWOLD (a 1990 book). The only thing new Mr Raduga brought to the table was the cycling of techniques, and when I have managed to apply those techniques (and it is extremely difficult to both stay still on waking and remember to apply the techniques) I haven't experienced a single thing that could be construed as either a step towards lucidity or a positive sign that the techniques are close to working and I should stick with them. |
|
To Ctharlhie: |
|
It normally takes me around 3-5mins to become lucid (because I fall asleep very quickly) but never as quickly as 15 seconds. I'm rather sceptical about the effectiveness of this technique as a whole because if you examine what actually goes on in the someone's brain between the transition from consciousness to sleep state, their EEG values reduce very significantly. I'm just doubtful as to whether humans can will themselves to reach lucidity in the manner described. |
|
Once again I'm hypnotised by your avatar... |
|
My Lucid Dreaming Articles/Tutorials:
Mindfulness - An Alternative Approach to ADA
Intent in Lucid Dreaming; Break that Dry-Spell, Escape the Technique Rut
Always, no sometimes think it's me,
But you know I know when it's a dream
I think I know I mean a yes
But it's all wrong
That is I think I disagree
-John Lennon
Bookmarks